Comments | trystan830: SN Ep ~ "Defending Your Life" (7x04)

trystan830

SN Ep ~ "Defending Your Life" (7x04)

Oct 14, 2011 22:33

i've tried various different approaches to my thinky posts after the episodes. i've tried running commentaries, but i miss stuff. i've tried recaps, but i forget stuff. and people really don't like clicking on cut links ( Read more... )

sn s7, supernatural, 7x04

Comments 14

hells_half_acre October 15 2011, 07:47:32 UTC

From the way it flashed to Amy, I had a feeling that the third witness was going to be her. Though, in my opinion, that's what Dean was feeling most guilty about so it really should have been Amy to come after him, not Jo.

That being said, I LOVED the Jo and Dean scene at the end. So very well done. Both actors are amazing as always. :)

trystan830 October 16 2011, 01:27:09 UTC

i thought it was going to be Amy too. i really thought Sam was going to find out from Osiris that Dean killed Amy, too.

and yes, that was an awesome scene. i've liked Jo since S2, unlike a good bit of the fandom. but then again, i've always been weird about that.

honscot October 15 2011, 21:11:09 UTC

There was no doubt in my mind that the third witness was going to be Amy a) because of what Dean said to the bartender, b) the fact that Sam thanked him for not killing Amy, c) it's Dean's most recent guilt, and yeah, d) they showed her in the opening flashbacks. Then again, maybe I'm wrong, maybe it was going to be someone else. Whoever it was, Dean really didn't want them to show up - I assumed because Sam was there, which leads me back to the theory that it was going to be Amy.

I thought it was a really great episode. The scene between Dean and Jo at the end was so touching. I find Dean's guilt and feelings of worthlessness to be absolutely heartbreaking, and Jensen's acting is amazing. I was in tears.

honscot October 15 2011, 22:16:09 UTC

Or maybe the third witness was going to be John. Goodness knows, Dean has always felt incredibly guilty about their dad dying (and going to hell) so he could live.

trystan830 October 16 2011, 01:28:49 UTC

heh yeah. it could have been anyone, really....

trystan830 October 16 2011, 01:28:07 UTC

i thought it was going to be Amy as well. and as i said above, i really thought Sam was going to find out from Osiris that Dean killed Amy, too.

and yes, both Jensen and Alona did a great job!

Thread 12