Review: Doctor Who S4EP6

May 11, 2008 10:26


Huh? What? Already on Episode 6? What's going on???

I'm going to keep this brief as I don't remember much.

- really bad skience (hurray) - the reproduction thing AND the planet thing. Oh well. The second one was more of a plot device, I suppose.
- Jenny is lovely. I wanted to be able to extrapolate relationship to Romana so badly. But never mind, I ( Read more... )

character: donna noble, fandom: reviews, tv: doctor who, character: martha jones, character: 10th doctor

Leave a comment

Comments 22

persiflage_1 May 11 2008, 10:31:12 UTC
- Martha's relationship with the Hath was sweet. Especially the principle one. However, it seemed a little OOC for her to burst into tears when he? sacrificed her life for her, imo? I don't know. It just jarred with me a bit.

He sacrificed himself for her... And I wrote fic to explain her reaction...

I love the look of the Hath - they're even cuter than the Ood !

Reply

tromana May 11 2008, 10:33:43 UTC
He sacrificed himself for her... And I wrote fic to explain her reaction...

So did Tom Milligan in LOTTL...

and now she's marrying not-him in lazy writing

I'll go have a look at your fic, though.

I love the look of the Hath - they're even cuter than the Ood !

Same!

Reply

persiflage_1 May 11 2008, 10:39:35 UTC
You'll have to hang on to read the fic - it's not posted yet. I wrote it long hand whilst at the launderette and need to type it up - and I've got to finish writing my Doctor introspective too - so expect both fics later today...

Reply

tromana May 11 2008, 10:40:39 UTC
Well, I'll look forward to them, then. :-)

Reply


sneakyangel May 11 2008, 13:29:17 UTC
I don't care what they say, I still firmly believe that Jenny is the lovechild of Four and Romana II!

I can't believe we are half way through the season already!

I think Jenny is a Gallifreyan, not a Time Lord. She didn't go the the Academy, therefore she didn't regenerate and she hasn't got that telepathy talent.

Reply

tromana May 11 2008, 16:29:49 UTC
I don't care what they say, I still firmly believe that Jenny is the lovechild of Four and Romana II!

Oooh... fair enough. Perhaps rewrite it so she is maybe??

I think Jenny is a Gallifreyan, not a Time Lord. She didn't go the the Academy, therefore she didn't regenerate and she hasn't got that telepathy talent.

That sounds fair enough. Although, the Doctor was assuming she had the ability to regenerate at one point. I think.

Reply

sneakyangel May 11 2008, 16:53:05 UTC
Perhaps rewrite it so she is maybe??
I challenge you! (again hehehe)

Although, the Doctor was assuming she had the ability to regenerate at one point. I think.
I think he did. But then she didn't. I remember when they made such a big deal about the Doctor realising who Yana was through the telepathic connection, so if Jenny had that ability, surely they would have at least mentioned it.

Reply

tromana May 11 2008, 16:56:03 UTC
I challenge you! (again hehehe)

It will TOTALLY veer off the actual storyline in parts, but why not? (Maybe even Romana appearing... that would be fun).

(And I KNEW the moment I said that, that was coming... why do I walk into these things??)

if Jenny had that ability, surely they would have at least mentioned it.

Indeed... I'm glad she remained alive though, potential returns are great.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up