Leave a comment

Comments 3

twistedyouth May 27 2005, 18:12:44 UTC
See, I just have the hardback with the three parts of Knightfall in one tome, so I have no idea what you're talking about with the interludes. I dunno... I probably wouldn't include them as part of the rating. They're kind of like bonus tracks on a cd... not actually part of the album.

Reply

andythesaint May 27 2005, 22:40:35 UTC
If they just tacked them on at the end, then maybe I'd treat them like bonus tracks. But, they're stuffed right in the middle of the story. You don't know to skip them until after you've read them.

(Plus, I'd probably include bonus tracks in a CD review as well)

Reply

twistedyouth May 28 2005, 02:46:31 UTC
But they weren't originally intended as part of the album. They might not have even been recorded in the same sessions. See my McCartney review for the bonus track thing.

http://www.livejournal.com/community/topfive_reviews/80347.html

Reply


Leave a comment

Up