Comments | tolkien100: Under the Trees (Challenge: Under the Trees)

hhimring in tolkien100

Under the Trees (Challenge: Under the Trees)

Feb 28, 2018 23:21

Title : Under the Trees ( Read more... )

author:hhimring, the silmarillion, challenge:under the trees, salgant, the history of middle earth, maeglin

Comments 6

liadtbunny March 1 2018, 15:51:21 UTC

I enjoyed this! The clothes line line made me laugh.

hhimring March 3 2018, 12:51:16 UTC

Glad that you enjoyed that bit!
Gondolin does sound a bit over-ornamental and solemn and in need of more clothes lines to me, sometimes!

fredbassett March 1 2018, 17:03:07 UTC

This is beautifully bittersweet, and the clothesline quip made me smile, too.

hhimring March 3 2018, 12:52:12 UTC

Thank you very much!
I'm glad you liked the mixed feelings here!

anna_wing March 5 2018, 09:42:10 UTC

That's very nice. I like Salgant, and it's good to have him be more than a buffoon.

hhimring March 6 2018, 00:19:04 UTC

Thank you!
I was intrigued both by Siadea's take on him and by Tehta's (although they are quite the opposite of each other)!
I do think he deserves another look.