The Two Sides Of Israel's BarrierThe Israeli wall is like stitches on a wound -- a painful, foreign and disfiguring presence that is nevertheless necessary to make the wound heal
( Read more... )
Maybe involuntary commitment to an insane asylum would be a better analogy here :) But I wasn't necessarily calling for forced treatment; just trying to give people a way to think about the current setup. You may not like a treatment but it can be good for you in the long-term. There may be a prohibition against forced treatment but there is no prohibition against nudging people to accept a treatment that's >good for them in the long term.
The letter was addressed more toward third-party observers: you may see a patient in pain from a treatment but you don't necessarily rush to "save" the patient from his doctor. Same here. The doctor here is -- reasonable people trying to find practical solutions that'll stick; the patient is -- people who don't look beyond their current emotions.
Clinton put it well: "To seek peace without compromise in this situation is not to seek peace at all."
Maybe involuntary commitment to an insane asylum would be a better analogy here :) Ok, but it really reminds me of the psychiatric institutions from >60 years ago
( ... )
The vast majority of poor people do not see terror as a valid outlet for their frustration with poverty. What feeds terrorism is warped notions of dignity and honor: when people don't have the brains or the will to achieve self-realization the hard way (build something, invent something that'll make others respect you!) and instead grab for the cheap cop-out of the form "i'll beat up my neighbor and then everyone will respect me for my big fists". Get a gun, and in one day there you are -- a freedom fighter, a _person_! How much faster and easier than to spend years studying and thinking so that you can build something useful
( ... )
Comments 5
the patient is illegal. So who is the patient here -- Israel, or Palestine?
Reply
The letter was addressed more toward third-party observers: you may see a patient in pain from a treatment but you don't necessarily rush to "save" the patient from his doctor. Same here. The doctor here is -- reasonable people trying to find practical solutions that'll stick; the patient is -- people who don't look beyond their current emotions.
Clinton put it well: "To seek peace without compromise in this situation is not to seek peace at all."
Reply
Reply
The vast majority of poor people do not see terror as a valid outlet for their frustration with poverty. What feeds terrorism is warped notions of dignity and honor: when people don't have the brains or the will to achieve self-realization the hard way (build something, invent something that'll make others respect you!) and instead grab for the cheap cop-out of the form "i'll beat up my neighbor and then everyone will respect me for my big fists". Get a gun, and in one day there you are -- a freedom fighter, a _person_! How much faster and easier than to spend years studying and thinking so that you can build something useful ( ... )
Reply
Leave a comment