I've Been Plagiarized

Apr 30, 2008 11:16

Many thanks to loriel_eris for alerting me to the fact that my Jack/Daniel fic Bruised was plagiarized and turned into a Jack/Ianto fic called Utility CupboardMuch scorn shall be heaped upon the plagiarist (who has deleted her journal). *scorn ( Read more... )

writing, wank, writing:plagiarism

Leave a comment

Comments 20

(The comment has been removed)

theemdash April 30 2008, 18:11:20 UTC
I don't understand why you'd want to steal a fic either. I mean, I just posted 2 fics and I have such joy when someone replies to say this part was funny or if they quote something back at me or if they love the same parts I do. But I'd have no sense of ownership if I hadn't written the words. I spent a lot of time replying to comments last night and really sharing some of my thoughts and processes and . . . what do you say if you didn't have those thoughts and processes?

I don't understand theft, particularly creative theft.

And yes, I do have a decent attitude about this. You should check out my commentary over here. :D

Reply

lady_ganesh May 3 2008, 03:29:37 UTC
You would've thought they would've at least taken the time to find fic that vaguely fit the canon, or made appropriate changes.

Reply


janedavitt April 30 2008, 17:12:00 UTC
YOU ARE KIDDING ME ::seethes:;

Gah.

::hugs you::

I just don't, and never will, get why people do it. The praise they get is meaningless as it's not for them.

Reply

theemdash April 30 2008, 17:33:08 UTC
You really should read the commentary on my flocked post.

Also, I'm going through her other fics and I found one that's a drabble and immediately thought of you. I can't get to your site from work, but if you want to take a quick look and see if it's familiar it's here

Reply

janedavitt April 30 2008, 17:43:12 UTC
Not one of mine, thank heavens (no one ever has plagiarized me; I'm glad as it gets messy while at the same time wondering sadly if I'm not worth nicking from ;-))

Reply

theemdash April 30 2008, 17:52:32 UTC
LOL! I'd nick from you any day. ;)

Reply


amedia April 30 2008, 17:31:41 UTC
That is such a HUGE HONOR. No one has ever plagiarized me.

:-(

Still, confusion to the plagiarist, and I'm glad it was caught and publicized!

Reply

theemdash April 30 2008, 18:12:49 UTC
LOL. A few people have responded that way. And it's my first time! Does that make me well known or something?

Reply


fluffymaru April 30 2008, 17:48:33 UTC

Your comments regarding why someone would steal fic match mine almost completely.

Deep down, they MUST know that the comments aren't aimed at them, yet they still do it. Conclusion? They have very, VERY sad little lives.

Still don't feel sorry for them. I would be LIVID.

::wishes she had a decent TW icon::

Reply

theemdash April 30 2008, 18:18:43 UTC
It's like attention seeking except not. I mean, okay, I understand taking credit for someone else's work if you're going to get a promotion or an award or something (I understand the motive, not y'know, actually doing it), but uh, if you're going to steal one of my fics to like get an award, might I suggest a different fic? I love Bruised and all, but I have better fics.

Y'know what else bothers me? I've been through the fics to see if I recognized any others and there's no sense of cohesion. I mean, it might be difficult to tell when comparing my angsty fics to my crackfic, but when you get down to the sentence level and how I punctuate, it's very clear that my fics were all written by the same person. Her collection was so wild and clearly not from the same person.

I mean, if you're going to plagiarize, aim for cohesion at least! :P

Reply

fluffymaru April 30 2008, 20:24:24 UTC

Haha!

Also, I like how she obviously has SOME measure of talent, since the changes were pretty darn decent. WTF is up with THAT? Usually, the people who gank fics are sad little 12-year-olds with no skill in the writing department and want in on all the fun...

People. Can't live with them, too much effort to kill them. Plus, who would steal read your fics?

Reply


audrich April 30 2008, 18:03:08 UTC
I think you've taken it very well.
I mean, there's borrowing with pride and then there's taking the piss.

*bookmarks the STOP! site*

Reply

theemdash April 30 2008, 18:20:52 UTC
I think I've taken it very well, too. Thank you. ;)

Reply


Leave a comment

Up