results: challenge ten [round two]

[sourpony]

Thank you so much to everyone who voted and stuck around with patience for this challenge to close. I really appreciate and I'm sorry for the delay but here they are.

Comments

[narniacmr]

Wow! I'm shocked, the icons were so gorgeous this round I didn't know if I would even make it through.
Thank you so much ♥

Comments for #2 & 6 please, unscreened is fine :)

[sourpony]

That's why I kept delaying for more votes because they were all so pretty!

least favorite donna: 02 - while the coloring really pops, the cropping and the diagonal really distracts from donna.
least favorite of the others: 06 - i love the cropping and the texture, however the coloring on the doctor lacks contrast and makes him blend in with the texture rather than stand out.
least favorite donna: 02- The white cuts the icon oddly.
east favorite donna: 02- The cropping is really awkward with the white versus the dark on the bottom of her face.

favorite donna: 02 -coloring is lovely and great use of texture for negative space

[tinitrinity]

I really wasn't expecting to make it through this round. The other icons were just so pretty! I'm just really shocked that I'm still here, tbh : D

Comments for 1 & 5, please. Either is fine : )

[sourpony]

least favorite donna: 01 - the blue background really distracts from donna, and the composition is kinda lopsided, perhaps is she were in the middle a bit more it would balance it all out.
least favorite of the others: 05 - the lines are kinda distracting and he appears really blurry but also kinda sharp around the edges of his jacket.
least favorite donna: 01 - The blue background, coupled with the white around Donna's head feels unnecassary. It would have been better with a little less editing.
least favorite of the others: 05 - the texture is too flashy and distracting

[wildalyss]

well didn't think i'd last as long as i did so yay for making it far!

comments unscreened for 3&4 bb

[sourpony]

♥

least favorite donna: 03 - icons blurry
least favorite of the others: 04 - doctor blends into background, doesnt stand out
least favorite of the others: 04 - The outline of the Doctor is rough and looks rushed. I do like the text you've used though!
least favorite donna: 03 - Honestly, this icon is seriously lovely... but the dark smudge over the right side of her face seems a little out of place. The image could have used the tiniest bit of sharpening in my opinion.
least favorite donna: 03 - the side of her face is too blurry and dark
least favorite of the others: 04 - The cutout of the Doctor seems a bit hard. The coloring on him doesn't quite match well to the dark blues of the background.

favorite of the others: 04 - love the negative space and the font on the text really works