Battle of the Generals

Jun 01, 2006 13:52


Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 26

wellsjc June 1 2006, 17:57:31 UTC
Lee.

Reply


BTW spicymachaggis June 1 2006, 17:58:52 UTC
I'm Biased. Pershing FTW.

... )

Reply

Re: BTW trouserminnow June 1 2006, 18:19:03 UTC
that is a sweet freaking tattoo.

Reply

Re: BTW spicymachaggis June 1 2006, 20:20:41 UTC
Looks a little distorted cuz my calf is wide at the top and really skinny at the bottom.
But yeah, I got it a few years ago when I was elected Commander of the FSU chapter of Pershing Rifles

Reply


sauce1977 June 1 2006, 18:08:48 UTC
Both were crafty, and Lee was the only reason the Confederacy existed for any length of time. Yet, Pershing served longer, served in many arenas, and if we're talking late career . . . Pershing probably would win.

There's an urban legend about Pershing here:

http://www.snopes.com/rumors/pershing.htm

Basically, he is rumored to have quickly suppressed Muslim guerillas in the Phillipines in 1911 by burial of killed combatants with pork.

If that's true, then it's genius. It's clearly hearsay, what I offer, but without that, Pershing's military success in numerous campaigns, plus his revered status to that of Washington, well, it pretty much lends a lot of weight on Pershing's side.

Reply

spicymachaggis June 1 2006, 20:26:52 UTC
It's also rumored that when Pershing got to France in WWI, he had the stupidest Sgt. in the AEF be his personal aide. When JJP would write orders, he would have the Sgt. read them.

If the Sgt. couldn't understand the orders JJP would dumb them down until he clearly understood them.
That way none of his orders could be misunderstood.

He is rumored to have done this because the officers of the time were obsessed with the failure of the Charge of the Light Brigade and never wanted any type of misunderstanding like that to happen under their command.

Reply

sauce1977 June 2 2006, 02:36:22 UTC
That is a solid communicator.

When it needs to be understood, it should be in plain text.

Reply


traviceratops June 1 2006, 18:52:04 UTC
Pershing's influence is clearly further-reaching.

Reply


enochson June 1 2006, 19:08:41 UTC
Pershing was cooler/better general in the long run.

But what it really all comes down to who had the better tank built in their name...


... )

Reply

themanwhowasdum June 1 2006, 19:46:07 UTC
thats a good view point, i based my decision on facial hair

Reply


Leave a comment

Up