Critique: - woah waaaaaaaay too much going on in the textures. The focus of the icon should be the image, but its hard to find it since the background is so busy.
- Very bland. No text, just Hinata and the crazy backround... not a pleasing contrast, I'm sorry...
- There's too much going on within this icon. The use of green is quite a lot. The texture behind doesn't need to be there at all.
- Hard to tell what subject is, sharp edges of the white on texture contrast too much with smoothness of picture in icon.
- I really love the overall composition of this icon; the only thing that I really have to say against it is that, with all the brushes, it appears far more busy that it should.
- The textures and design on the outside are very distracting and I don't even notice the middle of the icon. It's also very blah and monotone. Nothing interesting about it.
- I'm not a big fan of what you did with Athrun. it doesnt seem like it was cut out super-well, and i dont like how you reflected him. it looks awkward with the lines in the background and stuff. Also, the text seems too plain or something.
- I like the use of the repeated, faded image, but the actual image looks grainy in places. That, and the monotone background makes the icon appear a bit bland.
- Honestly? I find the colouring a bit too dull. :|
- The repeated face just looks really awkward. And the cut out of the guy looks pixel-y.
Comments:
- THe colours all work well with the subject. The background does not subtract from he subject.
- The icon's oversharpened, and the use of text wasn't the best, either.
- The colours was alright but the text border really distracted the whole icon. The border should blend with the colours of the icon.
Comments:
- the one thing i dont like about this icon is the width of the text outline, but besides that, i really like it. i like how the colors are sharpened, and just overall it looks cool.
- The coloring is gorgeous, the cropping is nice, and the text is handled well. Overall, it's just a nicely put-together icon.
- i love the coloring and cropping in this icon.
(Most Original Design)
- I can't say that I've seen an icon in this style before. I love how the text is not on the side, top or the bottom corner, nor is it in a nice little box. It's a little off center. But I tihnk it works. I've seen alot of the design styles here ALOT.
Comments 23
and i'd like to see my comments/critiques, please! #4
Reply
- The text is hard to read and does not stand out much from the background. The part of the text under the texture is especially hard to read to me.
- Pretty plain, and the colors look too muted.
Comments:
- Icon is simple yet the icon presents itself very well aesthetically.
Once again, sorry about the mistake. ^-^; That's what I get for posting the results when I'm sick...
Reply
Reply
may i have my critique for #3?^^
Reply
Critique:
- woah waaaaaaaay too much going on in the textures. The focus of the icon should be the image, but its hard to find it since the background is so busy.
- Very bland. No text, just Hinata and the crazy backround... not a pleasing contrast, I'm sorry...
- There's too much going on within this icon. The use of green is quite a lot. The texture behind doesn't need to be there at all.
- Hard to tell what subject is, sharp edges of the white on texture contrast too much with smoothness of picture in icon.
- I really love the overall composition of this icon; the only thing that I really have to say against it is that, with all the brushes, it appears far more busy that it should.
- The textures and design on the outside are very distracting and I don't even notice the middle of the icon. It's also very blah and monotone. Nothing interesting about it.
Now it's time to go sleep. xD
Reply
Reply
- I'm not a big fan of what you did with Athrun. it doesnt seem like it was cut out super-well, and i dont like how you reflected him. it looks awkward with the lines in the background and stuff. Also, the text seems too plain or something.
- I like the use of the repeated, faded image, but the actual image looks grainy in places. That, and the monotone background makes the icon appear a bit bland.
- Honestly? I find the colouring a bit too dull. :|
- The repeated face just looks really awkward. And the cut out of the guy looks pixel-y.
Comments:
- THe colours all work well with the subject. The background does not subtract from he subject.
Reply
I would love both a banner and critique for mine #2. ^^
Reply
- The icon's oversharpened, and the use of text wasn't the best, either.
- The colours was alright but the text border really distracted the whole icon. The border should blend with the colours of the icon.
Comments:
- the one thing i dont like about this icon is the width of the text outline, but besides that, i really like it. i like how the colors are sharpened, and just overall it looks cool.
- The coloring is gorgeous, the cropping is nice, and the text is handled well. Overall, it's just a nicely put-together icon.
- i love the coloring and cropping in this icon.
(Most Original Design)
- I can't say that I've seen an icon in this style before. I love how the text is not on the side, top or the bottom corner, nor is it in a nice little box. It's a little off center. But I tihnk it works. I've seen alot of the design styles here ALOT.
Reply
( ... )
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
...<<
SKIIIILZ! >D >D >D *is shot* ^__^
Reply
You did get a comment for Best Typography, though. =P
- i wish i knew what font the cursive is from, because i really like that font. the sideways touch is nice as well.
Reply
Leave a comment