That makes sense. Just something about the way he was like YOU TOOK IT FROM ME *angryface* made it seem, idk, bigger than that. But I'll take that explanation. :)
Dear Show, we all know that Sam still had the knife in 5.17 because he did a kick ASS epic knife battle with it and Dean even assisted on that last gorgeous double demon kill and I don't exactly seeing Meg after 5.10. I just assumed Meg took it off of Sam when he was unconscious. They didn't show that, granted, but...
That makes sense. Just something about the way he was like YOU TOOK IT FROM ME *angryface* made it seem, idk, bigger than that. But I'll take that explanation. :)
Did you download my brain or something? You have so many thoughts and conspiracy ideas that I do! OMG! So I’ll reply at length!
2) So Samuel wants Mary from Crowley - I have to give that one a great big 'ol DUH, show. But Samuel calling out Dean's secret? OH NO YOU DINNIT. OH. EM. CHEESE. Ilu, you great big giant bald freak of nature, just for that. (But you are of the dumb. CROWLEY DINNA BRING YOU BACK YOU TWIT.)
The Grandpappy thing was dumb. I was under the impression he wanted to save her soul, not bring her back to life. She’s the same age as her sons! Awkward! I’m not sure if Samuel was implying Dean should have let Sam die in the house fire or that he should let Sam go soulless….iz cunfuzed and must rewatch.
4)CAAAAAAAS. You learned that just from watching the pizza man? Color me impressed. O.o Also stop being a lying liarface who lies about Sam's soul. *severe frown* I believe this too. I don’t think Sam’s soul is in the cage. However, I do think Cas wants not!Sam to stay disconnected from his soul. Sam’s soul is
( ... )
Well, I do think that Mary's soul is in purgatory. So presumably if she came back to life and then died as a normal human and moved on she'd be bumped up to Heaven.
I do think maybe Sam's soul is in the cage, but it definitely doesn't have to be. It *could* be anywhere. That's what I like about this season, there are so many ways that any one plot line could go. ♥
YES. THE LONG CON. I love it. Season 4 was one of my favorite seasons EVER. So many mysteries. *hugs Show*
Am i the only one who thinks that Grandpa wanting his *daughter* back more than his wife is just...creepifying? Gah, it just rubs me *all* the wrong way.
*shudders*
Meg kicks *ass*, dear gods, and that kiss with Castiel.... *swoons*
I see the creepiness, but the thing is, Mary wasn't a "person" when her soul went out in that burst of fire - she was Something Else, so it's probable that she's in Purgatory - if she were in Hell Dean would've learned about it while down there, I'd bet. So if Deanna is in heaven and Mary is in Purgatory, maybe Samuel is trying to get her out of there (and hence he has a vested interest in helping Crowley find Purgatory and may continue the search now Crowley is (SOB SOB) gone.
It's very possible. I dunno if Show is going to go that way, but i kinda think that if Mary were in Purgatory, Samuel would have *said* something. I mean - it would have made his case so much stronger.
If Mary's in heaven, she'd kick his *ass* for taking her out of there, and does he really think that her seeing her two battered, fucked up, *hunter* sons will make her joyful?
Eh. Just a bad, bad, plan. I hope she's not in Purgatory, though. That would suck.
Comments 29
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
I just assumed Meg took it off of Sam when he was unconscious. They didn't show that, granted, but...
Reply
Reply
2) So Samuel wants Mary from Crowley - I have to give that one a great big 'ol DUH, show. But Samuel calling out Dean's secret? OH NO YOU DINNIT. OH. EM. CHEESE. Ilu, you great big giant bald freak of nature, just for that. (But you are of the dumb. CROWLEY DINNA BRING YOU BACK YOU TWIT.)
The Grandpappy thing was dumb. I was under the impression he wanted to save her soul, not bring her back to life. She’s the same age as her sons! Awkward! I’m not sure if Samuel was implying Dean should have let Sam die in the house fire or that he should let Sam go soulless….iz cunfuzed and must rewatch.
4)CAAAAAAAS. You learned that just from watching the pizza man? Color me impressed. O.o Also stop being a lying liarface who lies about Sam's soul. *severe frown* I believe this too. I don’t think Sam’s soul is in the cage. However, I do think Cas wants not!Sam to stay disconnected from his soul. Sam’s soul is ( ... )
Reply
I do think maybe Sam's soul is in the cage, but it definitely doesn't have to be. It *could* be anywhere. That's what I like about this season, there are so many ways that any one plot line could go. ♥
YES. THE LONG CON. I love it. Season 4 was one of my favorite seasons EVER. So many mysteries. *hugs Show*
Reply
You've read this fic, right?
Reply
That'd be a comforting thought, but I don't think I've ever known Show to be so kind.
*reads again*
PS - HOW BAD DO I WANT GABRIEL BACK, SERIOUSLY. *sob*
Reply
*shudders*
Meg kicks *ass*, dear gods, and that kiss with Castiel....
*swoons*
Yis. :)
Reply
Reply
If Mary's in heaven, she'd kick his *ass* for taking her out of there, and does he really think that her seeing her two battered, fucked up, *hunter* sons will make her joyful?
Eh. Just a bad, bad, plan. I hope she's not in Purgatory, though. That would suck.
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment