I know I go on about this...

Aug 07, 2009 20:52

... but seriously, I think it's time someone did.

Time to roughly update the score: (from racebending on LJ)

--------------------------
Avatar: the Last Airbender
--------------------------
Air Nomads: Tibetan monks
Water Tribe: Inuit / Yupik / Aborigine
Fire Nation: Imperial Japan
Earth Kingdom: China

--------------------------
The Last Airbender
----------- ( Read more... )

fail, phail, racebending

Leave a comment

Comments 7

nemogbr August 10 2009, 04:04:06 UTC
As others have stated, Shyamalan/Paramount have turned this from an Asian themed answer to Harry Potter to a generic European fantasy tale.

Still another year and we shall see what happens when the people interested in film search for the original material.

Lord of the Rings.
Harry Potter had increased readership due to the films.

I remember the same thing happened with Jurassic Park, Davinci Code.

DVD series are more accessible in comparison to books. It will be alot easier for them to see the blatant dishonour to the series.

Reply


nemogbr August 10 2009, 13:54:25 UTC
Air Nomads: Tibetan/Shaolin hybrid

Water Tribe: Inuit / Yupik / Aborigine

Fire Nation: Tang Dynasty China/Feudal Japan hybrid, Mongolian (Rough Rhinos), Mesoamerican (Sun Warriors)

Earth Kingdom: Chinese, Korean, Manchu, Bedouins (Sandbenders), Japanese (Kyoshi Warriors), Nepal (Smellerbee), Amazonian Indians (Foggy Swamp. Yes, I know they speak with US Southern Accents. That's a "country" accent. Every country has their own version of that accent). I think the Cabbage Merchant is Uyghur or Hui.

Reply

syonanto August 10 2009, 16:35:41 UTC
Woah... looks like you've done your research! Awesome job.

About the Swamp benders; I read somewhere that they were assumed to be Vietnamese? Doesn't really make that much sense to me, aside from skin color. As always, environment and tools need to be taken into perspective, and I kind of always thought of them as Amazonian myself.
And then I noticed the housing in the background of http://piandao.org/screencaps/ep24/ep24-1473.png and it threw me off again.

Reply


lexy_opal August 16 2009, 12:57:06 UTC
Um, hey! I've seen you around quite a bit in Avafandom and I just stumbled onto your journal.

This is an issue I'm passionate about as well. I feel deeply saddened and angry about the movie adaption. And I'm also a member of Racebending.

Would it be okay for me to add you?

Reply

syonanto August 16 2009, 22:46:42 UTC
Cool! Ha ha, are you on deviantART as well, by any chance? ^_^ We should add each other there, too!

Reply

lexy_opal August 17 2009, 00:28:48 UTC
I am! That would be cool, but I do only collect art. Because my art skills are only somewhat better than Sokka's. XD I'm Lexy-X there.

Reply

syonanto August 18 2009, 01:54:06 UTC
XD Well, even Sokka's art skills are truly unique!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up