the naming of menus is a curious thing

Mar 11, 2009 04:10

Take a look at, say, this. The links (in the current layout, in a graphical browser, they are to the right of the statistics) saying things like Grant Access/Subscribe/Track User/Send Message form a menu. We need to call that menu something, and our doc team is having a rough time figuring out what, so
Read more... )

dreamwidth

Leave a comment

Comments 65

dawnarrives March 11 2009, 08:22:43 UTC
I think maybe "profile action" or "profile navigation" are a little hollow sounding and maybe something different for the link titles too? I'd think "User interaction menu" would be better. :)

Reply

druidspell March 11 2009, 20:56:48 UTC
I agree--User Interaction is what I think of; to me, profile navigation is the menu about your bio, your subscribers, etc. And Profile Action seems like stuff that you're doing to your own profile.

Reply


jai_dit March 11 2009, 08:24:31 UTC
Navigation links make me think you're going away from the profile to some other place. Action links describe functionality while leaving flexibility in case more profile menus are added later.

Reply


sholio March 11 2009, 08:44:37 UTC
"User menu" is what immediately sprang to mind for me.

Reply

andrewducker March 11 2009, 09:36:00 UTC
User menu sounds right to me too. It's on the profile, but it's not to do with the profile...

Reply

quivo March 11 2009, 10:39:57 UTC
"User menu" sounds right to me too.

Reply

cjsherwood March 11 2009, 11:07:51 UTC
*chiming in*
That's where I was heading, also.... it doesn't feel like any of the tasks you were proposing had much to do with what I think of when one says "profile".

Reply


anatsuno March 11 2009, 08:51:04 UTC
User Menu and User Interaction both spring to mind first but that's when we /know/ what's in the menu - when of course a menu's name should be clear to indicate just that to someone who doesn't know it yet/ In that respect both fail, imo, because they drag the mind to other places.

Now, perhaps 'User InteractionS', plural, would help clarify ('this is going to be a list of possible interactions'). Or perhaps something even further away, removing the vocabulary of 'user': 'Relationships' ? Didn't you name the whole T+F from WTF 'Circle'? In which case could this be, if not 'manage Circle' (I know that's something else), at least something close to that? Related? *thinks* Hmm.

Reply

sholio March 11 2009, 08:53:37 UTC
What about "networking"?

Reply

anatsuno March 11 2009, 08:55:48 UTC
OhOH, not bad, yeah.

Reply

sholio March 11 2009, 10:02:47 UTC
It's basically just springboarding off your comment; I hadn't even thought about turning it around and looking at what all the options *do* until you broke it down like you did. :D

Reply


pauamma March 11 2009, 08:52:37 UTC
Commented on the dw_docs entry.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up