Harper's Island

[sweetiejen]

I'm liking Harper's Island. Anyone else watching?

I have a prediction on who the killer is.

Comments

[dubiously]

Oh, goodness, I have NO CLUE who the killer is going to be! I've decide to wait until eps 6-7 before I throw my hat in the ring and try to guess.

But Jimmy is a good guess! He is suspiciously nice. He's definitely got something up his sleeve, I think. It seems like everyone else on this show has an angle.

And, ugh, I don't like Abby either. She seems a little bit too Perfectly Lovable with the Troubled Past.

[sweetiejen]

Yes, I agree with all of this! Jimmy does seem suspiciously nice. C'mon, helping out little old ladies? Another good reason to believe it's him!

[littleone87]

Aww, I hope it's not Jimmy, I love Jimmy! :P

I recognized Henry from the former WB show "Popular." :)

[sweetiejen]

Haha, he's okay. I'm not super attached to any of the characters (probably because I know this is only a 13-episode series and most of them will die anyway!).

[ladyanne04]

In the newspaper article that Abby saw at the newspaper office last week, the picture of Wakefield was one of the cylons on BSG (he was also in a really early ep of Supernatural). Which totally make me think that Wakefield's not really dead - duh, duh, duh.

Trish's dad has crossed my mind a few times - I could see him being involved with some of the killings, but he has no real reason to go after the island people for the most part, unless it's to throw people off his track.

Jimmy would be a real twist - I totally wouldn't have suspected him. He helps little old ladies and is so the perfect ex-boyfriend (which may make him the perfect killer!)

Or . . . maybe there are two murderers!!

Anyway, it's kind of cheesy, but I have to say I'm totally hooked on this show now. The husband and I both yelled Bobby when he first showed up!

[sweetiejen]

Wow, nice catch! That would certainly lead us to believe that Wakefield will be in the series. However, he could always just be around in flashbacks, or as you said, may have an accomplice. Interesting!

I'm loving the show too... I'm sad it won't be around for long! It's a great concept for television.

[lizzieone]

I LOVE Jimmy but I do not think it is him. (I wouldn't mind him sticking the entire season though). I think the killer is Malcolm.

http://lizzieone.livejournal.com/

i wrote all my thoughts and predictions here. Please take the time to read it!!

[sweetiejen]

Interesting thoughts!

I don't see it being Malcolm, especially after last episode. He doesn't seem to have it in him to be a ruthless murderer.