Wankage in artists_beware

Apr 12, 2008 01:27

There are nutcases everywhere. This is no different. Ditto storm-artists. I bet dA has about eighty of these and someone is desperately waving a ban wand over there to try and control the riots. Apparently the sky is falling, all artworks are going to need bazillions of bucks to be registered to protect from losing your right to copyright... About ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 6

surrealist_geek April 12 2008, 07:25:02 UTC
But drama is so much more fun than sense...

Reply

subjectx52873m April 12 2008, 16:02:59 UTC
You have a point.

Reply


lilenth April 12 2008, 12:38:56 UTC

It's still a threat to people's livelihoods, if it gets passed (one or two rejections have not removed it from the running) then it'll threaten the livelihoods of every freelance artist out there.

We'll spend so much time hunting down thieves and people reposting our works sans watermark or sans copyright information that we won't have time to do art quite frankly. We can register, watermark and sign our work, it won't protect it from some git who removes the watermark and signature then claims he can't find the artist and he's "looked everywhere".

Not to mention, it would heavily clash with existing copyright law. Yes, people are being overly dramatic over it but this thing is being implemented by government agents who have no idea about what they're doing, the freelance market is already struggling, this bill if it passes will be the final nail in the coffin for it.

Reply

subjectx52873m April 12 2008, 16:02:15 UTC
Not completely disagreeing, it really all depends on the implementation. With the current plan someone that claims they can't find the artist, and in fact has not done a through search will get nailed for it later. It's not much different from current copyright laws and what happens today.

The problem is how do you enforce a copyright on an image that has no verifiable owner? That's what this bill is supposed to address.

Reply

lilenth April 12 2008, 16:49:58 UTC

Do you really trust them to implement it properly? I mean seriously.

Reply

subjectx52873m April 12 2008, 16:03:36 UTC
Also, you're reacting way to strongly to this.

As said above "this is partially a satire. It's got too much truth to be a full satire."

Reply


Leave a comment

Up