Plagiarism by Saturn's Heart
I would like to report that user Saturn's Heart on Fanfiction.net has plagiarized stories from at least 3 different authors - Lord Chaos/His lordship Chaos, blue/Blue Jeans, and Raziel12. She has posted these stories, claiming them as her own, on multiple different archives under the names Empress of Silence and WindGoddessHaruka. The ones that I have been able to find as of right now are listed below:
http://www.fanfiction.net/u/868236/Saturn-s-Heart
http://archiveofourown.org/users/EmpressOfSilence/pseuds/EmpressOfSilence/works
http://fanfic-4all.com/stories/viewuser.php?uid=2330
Case 1 - Circles of Time: The Messiah Wars
Chapter 1
Hers: http://archiveofourown.org/works/762267/chapters/1426614
Original: http://www.oocities.org/tokyo/9897/ctdrkms1.txt
Chapter 2
Hers: http://archiveofourown.org/works/762267/chapters/1432561
Original: http://www.oocities.org/tokyo/9897/ctdrkms2.txt
Chapter 3
Hers: http://archiveofourown.org/works/762267/chapters/1432564
Original: http://www.oocities.org/tokyo/9897/ctdrkms3.txt
Chapter 4:
Hers: http://archiveofourown.org/works/762267/chapters/1445837
Original: http://www.oocities.org/tokyo/9897/ctdrkms3.txt
This story was originally written by my husband as part of a larger collaboration known as the Circles of Time series in which different authors all wrote stories to expand on the CoT universe. Each story was a stand alone story, but also part of the larger collection all of which was archived here http://www.oocities.org/Tokyo/9897/cttime.htm. My husband's authorship of these stories can be verified by the other authors who contributed to Circles of Time.
Saturn's Heart had also stolen another one of my husband's stories "1101", however this story has already been removed either by her or by the admins on her fanfiction.net account however it's theft can be confirmed by at least 2 other people - one of whom acted as the beta reader when my husband was originally writing the story.
Case 2 - Consuming Me
Hers: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/9202501/1/Consuming-Me
Original: http://www.dotmoon.net/library_storyview.php?chapterid=768
Case 3 - Dreams of Unreflected Sufferings
Hers: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/9204701/1/Dream-of-Unreflected-Sufferings
Original: http://www.dotmoon.net/textfiles/217.txt
Case 4 - Wishes
Hers: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/9219628/1/Wishes
Original: http://www.dotmoon.net/library_storyview.php?chapterid=767
Case 5 - Portrait of an Old Man
Hers: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/9219636/1/Portrait-of-an-Old-Man
Original: http://www.dotmoon.net/library_storyview.php?chapterid=764
Case 6 - Sailor Moon Requiem
Hers: http://archiveofourown.org/works/691215/chapters/1270126
Original: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2531004/1/Sailor-Moon-Requiem
Case 7 - Requiem Redux
Hers: http://archiveofourown.org/works/691285/chapters/1270252
Original: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2592842/1/Sailor-Moon-Requiem-Redux
Case 8 - Sailor Moon: Requiem of Silence
Hers: http://archiveofourown.org/works/657728/chapters/1198932
Original: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/3805698/1/Sailor-Moon-Requiem-of-Silence
Saturn's Heart has also posted the stories "Consuming Me", "Dreams of Unreflected Sufferings", "Wishes" and "Portrait of an Old Man" claiming them as her own on archiveofourown.org and fanfic-4all.com (as Empress of Silence and WindGoddessHaruka respectively). While on archiveofourown it lists these stories have publishing dates in April 1992 these dates are false. The same goes for the original publication date of Circles of Time on archiveofourown.
As far as I've been able to gather this particular archive allows users to input these dates themselves which is evident by the fact that Empress of Silence's profile shows she only joined the site in 2011. Another fact that supports the falsification of these publish dates is the fact that the Sailor Moon series itself did not begin being published as a manga in Japan until sometime in February 1992 and did not become an anime until 1993. In addition to this, for those not familiar with Sailor Moon, the characters (Michiru/Sailor Neptune, Haruka/Sailor Uranus, and Mistress Nine/Hotaru/Sailor Saturn) in the stories are actually characters who are not introduced until the 3rd arc of the series which was not available in Japan as manga or anime until 1994 - and did not make it's way over to the U.S until 1999 as a manga and 2000 as an anime. The falsification of these dates is also supported by the authors own claim on her fanfiction.net profile that she had written each of these stories 11 years ago which would give them publish dates of 2002.
I have spoken to both my husband and blue, they both verify the fact that they have never posted stories under the names Saturn's Heart, Empress of Silence, or WindGoddessHaruka and that said author did not collaborate on any of the stories that she is claiming as her own. I have already made reports to fanfiction.net regarding the plagiarism of blue's stories there and to archiveofourown regarding the Circles of Time story however as of this time all the stories still remain up.
As I had only just discovered the possible plagiarism of Sailor Moon Requiem, Requiem Redux, and Sailor Moon: Requiem of Silence I have not yet been able to contact Raziel12 however I intend on doing that shortly to inform her of her stories' theft.
I will be endeavoring to get screen captures of all of Saturn Heart's works in the event that she deletes them and saving copies to my hard-drive. I hope that everyone here will be able to help me prove this author's blatant theft of other's stories and get the author to admit their wrong doing.
http://www.fanfiction.net/u/868236/Saturn-s-Heart
http://archiveofourown.org/users/EmpressOfSilence/pseuds/EmpressOfSilence/works
http://fanfic-4all.com/stories/viewuser.php?uid=2330
Case 1 - Circles of Time: The Messiah Wars
Chapter 1
Hers: http://archiveofourown.org/works/762267/chapters/1426614
Original: http://www.oocities.org/tokyo/9897/ctdrkms1.txt
Chapter 2
Hers: http://archiveofourown.org/works/762267/chapters/1432561
Original: http://www.oocities.org/tokyo/9897/ctdrkms2.txt
Chapter 3
Hers: http://archiveofourown.org/works/762267/chapters/1432564
Original: http://www.oocities.org/tokyo/9897/ctdrkms3.txt
Chapter 4:
Hers: http://archiveofourown.org/works/762267/chapters/1445837
Original: http://www.oocities.org/tokyo/9897/ctdrkms3.txt
This story was originally written by my husband as part of a larger collaboration known as the Circles of Time series in which different authors all wrote stories to expand on the CoT universe. Each story was a stand alone story, but also part of the larger collection all of which was archived here http://www.oocities.org/Tokyo/9897/cttime.htm. My husband's authorship of these stories can be verified by the other authors who contributed to Circles of Time.
Saturn's Heart had also stolen another one of my husband's stories "1101", however this story has already been removed either by her or by the admins on her fanfiction.net account however it's theft can be confirmed by at least 2 other people - one of whom acted as the beta reader when my husband was originally writing the story.
Case 2 - Consuming Me
Hers: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/9202501/1/Consuming-Me
Original: http://www.dotmoon.net/library_storyview.php?chapterid=768
Case 3 - Dreams of Unreflected Sufferings
Hers: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/9204701/1/Dream-of-Unreflected-Sufferings
Original: http://www.dotmoon.net/textfiles/217.txt
Case 4 - Wishes
Hers: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/9219628/1/Wishes
Original: http://www.dotmoon.net/library_storyview.php?chapterid=767
Case 5 - Portrait of an Old Man
Hers: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/9219636/1/Portrait-of-an-Old-Man
Original: http://www.dotmoon.net/library_storyview.php?chapterid=764
Case 6 - Sailor Moon Requiem
Hers: http://archiveofourown.org/works/691215/chapters/1270126
Original: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2531004/1/Sailor-Moon-Requiem
Case 7 - Requiem Redux
Hers: http://archiveofourown.org/works/691285/chapters/1270252
Original: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2592842/1/Sailor-Moon-Requiem-Redux
Case 8 - Sailor Moon: Requiem of Silence
Hers: http://archiveofourown.org/works/657728/chapters/1198932
Original: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/3805698/1/Sailor-Moon-Requiem-of-Silence
Saturn's Heart has also posted the stories "Consuming Me", "Dreams of Unreflected Sufferings", "Wishes" and "Portrait of an Old Man" claiming them as her own on archiveofourown.org and fanfic-4all.com (as Empress of Silence and WindGoddessHaruka respectively). While on archiveofourown it lists these stories have publishing dates in April 1992 these dates are false. The same goes for the original publication date of Circles of Time on archiveofourown.
As far as I've been able to gather this particular archive allows users to input these dates themselves which is evident by the fact that Empress of Silence's profile shows she only joined the site in 2011. Another fact that supports the falsification of these publish dates is the fact that the Sailor Moon series itself did not begin being published as a manga in Japan until sometime in February 1992 and did not become an anime until 1993. In addition to this, for those not familiar with Sailor Moon, the characters (Michiru/Sailor Neptune, Haruka/Sailor Uranus, and Mistress Nine/Hotaru/Sailor Saturn) in the stories are actually characters who are not introduced until the 3rd arc of the series which was not available in Japan as manga or anime until 1994 - and did not make it's way over to the U.S until 1999 as a manga and 2000 as an anime. The falsification of these dates is also supported by the authors own claim on her fanfiction.net profile that she had written each of these stories 11 years ago which would give them publish dates of 2002.
I have spoken to both my husband and blue, they both verify the fact that they have never posted stories under the names Saturn's Heart, Empress of Silence, or WindGoddessHaruka and that said author did not collaborate on any of the stories that she is claiming as her own. I have already made reports to fanfiction.net regarding the plagiarism of blue's stories there and to archiveofourown regarding the Circles of Time story however as of this time all the stories still remain up.
As I had only just discovered the possible plagiarism of Sailor Moon Requiem, Requiem Redux, and Sailor Moon: Requiem of Silence I have not yet been able to contact Raziel12 however I intend on doing that shortly to inform her of her stories' theft.
I will be endeavoring to get screen captures of all of Saturn Heart's works in the event that she deletes them and saving copies to my hard-drive. I hope that everyone here will be able to help me prove this author's blatant theft of other's stories and get the author to admit their wrong doing.