r2c2 - voting

[sianna_sm]

Skipping;
---> restlessme (no byes remaining)
---> lady_rock (no byes remaining)
---> alwaysparis (one byes remaining)
---> diving_too_deep (no byes remaining)
---> nutmeg_05 (no byes remaining)

Eliminated;
---> dark_x_huntress (failure to enter with no byes remaining)
---> alexzrules (failure to enter with no byes remaining)
---> csichick_2 (failure to enter with no byes remaining)

Voting Rules;---> Voting will stay up until Sunday

Comments

[mayfrayn]

Voting Off:
WORST(-1 points): #04 - the colouring is good but the cropping cut the eys in an awkward way
WORST(-2 points): #08 - though the icon is quite original, the final resutl is a little too confused, and there is low contrast in the image of the subject
Favorites:
FAVORITE (+1 points): #05 - the texture on the background is original, and fits well with the subject
FAVORITE (+2 points): #06 - nice colouring and good cropping, that focusses well on the subject

[fahrenheit1993]

Voting Off:
WORST(-1 points): #07 - Although having a great crop, the colouring is too pink/purple and makes the icon looks odd.
WORST(-2 points): #10 - Though the cropping is good, texts don't fit at all.
Favorites:
FAVORITE (+1 points): #05 - Great use of texture and blending, though more colouring is needed.
FAVORITE (+2 points): #08 - Awesome use of textures and cropping/blending. This is just great.

[graymarks]

Voting Off:
WORST(-1 points): #10 - placement of text is odd and distracts from the focus of the icon, and the image is slightly over sharpened around Kristen's face.
WORST(-2 points): #01 - The light added to the left of the icon distracts the eye. The image could also do with a little more contrast to give some depth.
Favorites:
FAVORITE (+1 points): #08 - great use of texture.
FAVORITE (+2 points): #11 - .

[melas_2ndsoul]

Voting Off:
WORST (-3 points): #07 Kristen's skin looks unnatural because it's so red... but the cropping is great
SECOND-WORST (-2 points): #03 - Kristen kind of disappears in the texture. The texture is the part that is more demandig because Kristen skins is very light
THIRD-WORST (-1 points): #11 - Because of the coloring Kristen's skin is the same color as the background behind her and that looks a little bit strange.

Favorites:
FAVORITE (+3 points): #05
SECOND-FAVORITE (+2 points): #08
THIRD-FAVORITE (+1 points): #10

[sianna_sm]

Please vote for 2 favourite and 2 worst icons =)
you can use the form~

[tiah15]

---> Vote for the one icon you think are of the worst quality (in descending order). Please vote based on the quality of the icons, not on your personal preference. Please vote based on the quality of the icons, not on your personal preference.

Did you mean to post that last sentence twice ? ;)

[sianna_sm]

Haha next time when I copy/paste I should check double xD Thank you =) I'm glad someone's reading the rules.
Btw you need to put numbers on your votes. I guess you forgot =)

[tiah15]

OOPS!