SPN character sorting meme

Oct 08, 2015 12:55

You can sort all (?) the SPN characters that have appeared in at least two episodes hereSome of these were super hard decisions (Jo vs Ellen? Jo vs Amelia???), but it shook out into something I'm pretty happy with, in about three tiers: top third are the characters I love, middle third are characters I have no or conflicting feelings towards, ( Read more... )

entry: meme, tv: spn

Leave a comment

Comments 9

ever_neutral October 9 2015, 01:26:51 UTC
Heh, I'm forever conflicted about Dean. He's downright unlikeable to me from S6 onwards, but I still find him one of the most INTERESTING characters, so he'd probably make my top five on that basis alone. O_o

Reply

snickfic October 9 2015, 20:20:05 UTC
I have Doylist vs Watsonian troubles with Dean, as in, I could find him more interesting if I didn't find the narrative a lot more sympathetic to him and his angst and his story than I am. That eventually became my problem with the show as a whole, really.

Reply


gryfndor_godess October 9 2015, 01:34:33 UTC
Augh, I did it and then accidentally clicked out of the window before I could save the results. /o\ My middle results seemed pretty good, but my top ones were weird, 1=Dean 2=Sam (IDGI, I'm pretty sure I only had 2 Sam questions, and if it had asked me Sam vs. Dean, I would have put both), 3=Jody, I think 4=Meg, and Bela was FIVE. O_o As if.

Reply

snickfic October 9 2015, 20:20:34 UTC
Ha ha. Obviously Bela at #1!

Reply


tipsy_kitty October 9 2015, 03:56:33 UTC
I placed Gwen higher than I would have expected too! And I tended to rate humans over demons over angels, mostly because angel motivations are so perplexing. So like, while Gabriel and Crowly can be fun, I'd much rather read a fic about Jo or Bela.

Reply

snickfic October 9 2015, 20:21:44 UTC
I agree very much about angel motivations. Like Anna - what was she doing in the back half of S4 when we didn't see her? What did she even want? WHO KNOWS. It's one of the reason I've never managed to write her.

Castiel's the exception, IMO. I usually feel like I know where I'm at with him.

Reply

tipsy_kitty October 9 2015, 22:38:10 UTC
Very true, but then, Cas has been written more like a human since season 5. Even when he's overreaching (new God) his motives make sense to me.

Reply


de_nugis October 9 2015, 16:21:49 UTC
I'm glad to see some more Rufus love.

I feel like the middle ranges could get pretty muddled, but my irritation with Samandriel was deep and true.

Reply

snickfic October 9 2015, 20:25:29 UTC
Rufus/Ellen remains my favorite Ellen ship. They could be so great.

I have just realized that I have a former student who looks a whole lot like Samandriel, which is an amusing but also alarming realization to have. And now I am thinking about all those many, many Samandriel/Adam fics I linked to in the early days of the rarepair newsletter...

Reply


Leave a comment

Up