Comments | skinsfans: POLL: Which character episode is your favorite?

katiefitch in skinsfans

POLL: Which character episode is your favorite?

Mar 27, 2011 17:11

Compare each character's episode to each other. That is, which one do you prefer for each character? Polls below, I split it up into generations. For the characters that only got one episode in the generation (Pandora, Naomi, Anwar, Sketch), I pitted them against each other. And which finales do you prefer within the generations?

( Generation 1 )

character: james cook, character: cassie ainsworth, character: tony stonem, character: naomi campbell, character: freddie mclair, character: anwar kharral, season 3: general discussions, character: sketch, season 1: discussions, character: effy stonem, character: emily fitch, character: pandora moon, - polls, season 2: discussions, character: chris miles, character: michelle richardson, character: jj jones, character: sid jenkins, character: thomas tomone, character: jal fazer, character: maxxie oliver, character: katie fitch, season 4: general discussions

Comments 49

Mod. immortality March 27 2011, 21:19:28 UTC

Can you please add a subject line to this post and tag it appropriately? Thanks.

(The comment has been removed)

Re: Mod. immortality March 27 2011, 21:22:11 UTC

Thanks. :)

cookiesmonsters March 27 2011, 21:28:03 UTC

So hard to pick between both Effy eps in gen1. I loved them both so much.

(The comment has been removed)

cookiesmonsters March 27 2011, 22:31:27 UTC

Love yours too <3

theafterimages March 27 2011, 21:33:50 UTC

I just wish there was a way to choose both of Sid's episodes, because imo they were two of the best generation one episodes.

(The comment has been removed)

theafterimages March 27 2011, 22:07:12 UTC

*nods* I went with his S2 episode as well because the way they handled his dad's arc and death was just so well done.

alluringcliche March 27 2011, 22:04:24 UTC

I was thinking this as well, it's funny because lately we've been talking a lot about the amount of hate Sid gets (I don't hate him), but I didn't realize his episodes were both SO good that he really doesn't deserve it.

Thread 8

perfectlystill March 27 2011, 21:35:13 UTC

Tony: 1x01
Cassie: 1x02
Jal: 2x08
Chris: 2x05
Sid: 1x05
Maxxie: 1x06
Michelle: 1x07
Effy: 1x08
Finale: series 1
Anwar or Sketch: Anwar

Cook: 4x03
Thomas: 3x03
Freddie: 4x05
JJ: 3x07
Effy: 3x08
Katie: 4x04
Emily: 3x09
Everyone: 3x01
Pandora or Naomi: Naomi

crystalbreaks March 27 2011, 21:42:30 UTC

I wish I could have voted for both Cassie episodes, they're both in my top 5. Her S1 episode seems to be winning, maybe I should have voted for 2x09 just to give it more love, but 1x02 just has a special place in my heart.

I first thought it was interesting how Gen 2 has one episode clearly beating the other in most cases, but then I remembered that it's S3 vs. S4 and...yeah.

theafterimages March 27 2011, 22:09:18 UTC

I thought 2x09 was a really good episode, too, but I had to go with 1x02 because it did such a stunning job of establishing her and getting us to see what life is like in her head, really.