A few more quibbles - no spoilers

Jul 28, 2007 13:04

One quibble with Harry Potter, and one quibble with the people reviewing it ( Read more... )

kids, reading, reviews

Leave a comment

Comments 3

padparadscha July 28 2007, 21:06:12 UTC
I always thought that one of the main problems with book banning is that it underestimates children. Look at Bridge to Terabithia, where often the arguments for banning it have to do with the religious discussions, or dealing with death. What I hear when people say kids shouldn't be exposed to such things is that the parents don't think the kids are smart enough to think about it critically. And even more ridiculous is when adults cite Bad Guys as Improper Role Models. Of COURSE they're improper role models. They're Bad Guys. Do they think kids can't recognize that and identify with the Good Guys instead?

I wrote something on this a while back, on how kids deserve more credit. I still think it's true.

Reply


zair99 July 28 2007, 22:21:49 UTC
I have successfully managed to avoid nearly all of the hubbub surrounding the book, the reviews, the spoilers, the hype, etc, and I'm quite happy about that. I am, however, dying to read the book! Can I borrow it when you're done? :D

Reply

skellington1 July 29 2007, 15:43:00 UTC
Ask my brother - I borrowed it from him.

Since my last post is spoiler-y and you can't read it, I'll just let you know now that my Dad cast you as Neville in his head.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up