Feedback Polls

[hsapiens]

Congratulations to fan_cifully, obaona, and winterfish! *throws confetti* Congrats to ALL of our participants, makers and voters. You make this community work and we hope to see everyone return for Round 3

Comments

[casett]

I am filling out the poll and thinking "which one was that"? I don't really remember each individual challenge by name or number so you can probably totally discount my vote. But I didn't use a skip because I tried every one so I found something in each one. But I ticked because "It's what I DO!"

But, you Mods and all the community members are great and I will be back to be kicked around some more next round.

[hsapiens]

Hmmm...I wonder if that speaks to the caps being unmemorable or the to the challenge names being unmemorable. ;-)

It wouldn't be the same without you so I'm extremely happy that you'll be returning for another round. Yay!

[casett]

It has nothing to do with the caps or the challenge names. It has more to do with perimenopausal memory!

[farscapeone]

I would like to see more of the goauld in the next challenges. while there were many enemies throughout Stargate the Goauld were the ones who really made Stargate happen and I would really like to get a chance to icon them more.

[hsapiens]

I want to state for the record that I did not pay you to make this comment. I was never happy with the Ori-as-main-villain; I SO preferred the goa'uld, campy though they often were, to a wall of CGI fire. When I very first started making icons, I made a set of icons that I thought Teal'c would make if he were an LJ iconner: all system lords, all dead. The execution leaves a lot to be desired but the idea of Teal'c pictorally cataloging the deaths of false gods still amuses me.

I thought that I was pretty much alone in my goa'uld love in icons because I see so few of them made or used.

[beeej]

I'm totally on board with this. While we've had some beautiful Ori icons in the contest, I never liked the Ori. I've always preferred the Goauld. :)

[hsapiens]

:) I'm looking forward to seeing more of our goa'uld nemeses in the next Round!

[supplyship]

I think you shouldn't worry about themes too much - I mean, you can't use them as criteria for voting, so it probably doesn't make much difference if you have them for challenges. Maybe just pick an episode and cap that?

Banner-making, count me in! :)

[scifi_tv_addict]

From what I recall (there were a lot of challenges and caps!), the main characters seemed to have been well represented. My biggest concern when I signed up for this competition was that newer characters (and villains) wouldn't be represented as strongly as the older characters - but the mods did a nice job balancing it all out. I think that's really what the priority for the caps should be, making sure to give icon-makers all sorts of different options to work with, not just the 'popular' choices. I may typically prefer one hero or villain over another, but who knows what caps will inspire me that week.

Having said that, I would like to see more secondary characters included. People like Landry or Carolyn or Lee or Reynolds. I can't really remember all that many caps of them.

Ideas for challenges? Hm...maybe a focus on body parts? (hair, only portions of the face, arms, etc) I saw this somewhere else and it resulted in some really interesting icons. Maybe something about 'tears,' we all love a little angst, right?

[jenniferjensen]

Count me in for the next round! I ♥ this LIMS Community :D