Alternates: Round 2 // Challenge 17

[hsapiens]

Did you create a few icons for the challenge and then choose the best one to submit? Did you make icons from the caps though you did not participate in the last challenge?

If so, this is where you can post those "rejected" icons (along with your submitted entry) and make them sharable to others.

Comments

[winterfish]

Submitted:

[farscapeone]

I loved your entered icon, the cropping was gorgeous and really original looking although I did think the colouring was a little dark.

[winterfish]

Thank you! :) Yeah, I wanted there to be a moodiness to the icon with light and dark, but I think I tipped into too dark on Ishta's side. Just a fraction lighter might have made it easier to see.

[advection]

I love the creativity of all of these -- really just love all these icons. The entered one and the second alternate are my favorites -- that's a really beautiful study of Ishta -- but the first alternate is super cool, and I love the last alternate (because it's Jack and Daniel, and also for the coloring and composition and the play of the framing texture against the bg texture).

Rockin' icons.

[aliline]

[winterfish]

I love your second alternate. The cropping and colouring are gorgeous.

[aliline]

thank you. :)

[advection]

I like the chilly blue of your entered icon -- the bleakness and the lighting make repliCarter seem extra horrifically mechanical, and both Carters still look beautiful and strong at the same time, which really appeals to me. And I just love everything about all three alternates.