Results: Round 4 // Challenge 12

Sep 16, 2010 20:02

Banner maker this week is beeej.

Results )

round 4.12, round 4.12:results, round 4, results

Leave a comment

Comments 7

txduck September 17 2010, 02:28:06 UTC
whew ... didn't think I was making through this round.

comments for #4 please, unscreened is fine

Reply

beeej September 17 2010, 02:49:09 UTC
- 4: (Although the cropping looks interesting, not much has been done with the colouring, it lacks in brightness and contrast, which makes a bit boring to the eye. Maybe adding a bit more of brightness and contrast would have worked better ( ... )

Reply


xafirah September 17 2010, 04:43:06 UTC
Oh well ;) Comments for #2 please, unscreened is fine.

Reply

beeej September 18 2010, 04:42:53 UTC
Congrats on getting to the semi-finals ( ... )

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

beeej September 18 2010, 04:43:36 UTC
- 1: While I like the crisp and clear nature of this icon, it's simply too plain compared to the others - it doesn't have that extra spark that brings it to the forefront.
+ 1: I like the coloring and cropping.
+ 1: Nice, close crop highlights the intense blue of Sam's eyes and the expression on her face. The light blue is a nice complement to the overall coloring of the icon.
+ 1: Love the delicate, light colouring, and the crop really emphasizes Sam's expression.
+ 1: (I love the angled crop - it's very visually interesting. I also like how bright and clear the image is, and the colors are great. )
+ 1: Wow. What absolutely beautiful coloring and clarity. Great crop, too. :)
+ 1: Beautiful bright colors.
+ 1: Such a great choice for the crop, and I really love the lightness and coloring. So very beautiful. Love it!
+ 1: Gorgeous coloring & lovely crop

Reply


jasminago September 18 2010, 12:45:02 UTC
Wut? I survived? *looks around a hidden camera*

Comments for #3, please. unscreened is fine. :)

Reply

beeej September 18 2010, 16:27:13 UTC
Congratulations on making it to the finals! :D

- 3: too dark around the edges and then the carter character is over-brightened
- 3: Image isn't crisp enough. Her face is far too blurry. I also am not a big fan of the darkening in the corners/edges. It looks a little too abrupt.
- 3: Not a least favorite, but rather my fourth most favorite of this bunch. I love the crop, coloring, and lighting effects. Lovely image quality and visible detail even with the image at such a small size.
- 3: It's too dark.
+ 3: Good colouring and crop and looks cool.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up