Results: Round 4 // Challenge 5

Jul 29, 2010 22:40

Banner maker this week is xafirah

Results )

round 4.05:results, round 4.05, round 4, results

Leave a comment

Comments 31

(The comment has been removed)

beeej July 30 2010, 02:53:26 UTC
- 1: Icon is overly brightened, and loses detail in Daniel's face. Also, the texture used on the left makes the icon looking pixillated.
- 1: (text is very difficult to read, not sharp enough)
- 01: The text in between their faces is rather distracting.

Reply


ga_unicorn July 30 2010, 02:46:44 UTC
Congratulations! to the winners. Terrific work!

Comments for #10, please. Unscreened is fine.

Reply

beeej July 30 2010, 02:54:10 UTC
- 10: This icon falls kind of flat - the coloring, the crop, both kind of blah.
- 10: Poor resolution, and the coloring is rather monochrome.
+ 10: Just clean and beautiful. I love the colors you used.

Reply


casett July 30 2010, 02:48:28 UTC
Still here! Thanks for the Mod's Choice.

Comments for #11 please.

Reply

beeej July 30 2010, 02:55:14 UTC
You're very welcome! That was a beautiful icon!

- 11: While I love the artistic flare & coloring used for the icon, it feels like "too much" and overpowers the image.
- 11: (The color is really glaring. And I like the border but the text is really not popping.)
- 11: (while I like the colouring, the icon is very pixilated and out of focus)
+ 11: This is so beautiful! It looks like a tiny watercolor painting! Fabulous job with a really difficult cap!
+ 11: I really enjoy the use of colour here. It's really great.

Reply


rightxhere July 30 2010, 03:09:21 UTC
Comment for #7 please, unscreened is fine.

Also, huge congrats to the winners!

Reply

beeej July 30 2010, 03:34:25 UTC
+ 7: (Great background, lovely coloring)

Reply


winterfish July 30 2010, 03:30:05 UTC
Wow, thank you everyone! Can I have comments for 17, please. Unscreened is fine.

Reply

beeej July 30 2010, 03:35:03 UTC
Congrats!

+ 17: Good color, cut, and clarity. I like Thor in triplicate, and the "lights" make it nice and alien-like. :)
+ 17: Aha, an extra Asgard! I like the addition, and the coloring and light globe thingies really give this a nice, ethereal feel - which is perfect for the Asgard, I think.
+ 17: (The coloring on this is GREAT. It really makes you curious about the Asgard.)
+ 17: Great blending and i adore the ligtening effect and the colouring. Such a pretty icon!
+ 17: I like the colour, texture and the use of the available cap several times.
+ 17: (Great idea, lovely background, they look really "alien")
+ 17: i love this, the duplication is perfect, though the background is simple there is a feeling of depth in the icon and i love the contrast and brightness and image placement
+ 17: I love the way you manipulated the cap to create the grouping of 3 Asgard, and the light texture and coloring are really lovely!
+ 17: I like the use of background texture on this icon. Also, the use of multiple Thor's was rather nice.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up