Round 5, Challenge 3 Voting

[arcaneidealist]

Comments

[graphixfairy]

LEAST FAVOURITE:
#02: misplaced texture
#03: too much going on and hard to read font

FAVOURITE:
#05: Great use of texture and negative space
#01: Pretty coloring and cropping

[pwrld]

LEAST FAVOURITE:
#01: The picture looks oversharpen and a little pixelated
#02: The texture is distracting and the b&w effect is a little dark.
FAVOURITE:
#04: Great crop and awesome use of coloring
#05: Nice texture and coloring

[littleangel1987]

LEAST FAVOURITE:
#05: The coloring is really bright, especially in her face. The image of Selena is a bit too grainy.
#01: The image is too sharp, makes the icon in some parts look pixelated.

FAVOURITE:
#06: Creative idea and well done with cropping and coloring.
#04: Great coloring and the background blurred enough to make Selena stand out.

[lady_kingsley]

LEAST FAVOURITE:
#2: This texture doesn't match the icon. Also contrast could be bigger.
#1: Icon is too oversharpened, Selena's face looks not like Selena.

FAVOURITE:
#5: Great idea with negative space, nice texture used here and coloring is matching icon perfect.
#6: Icon is simple but preety. Nice texture used here, coloring and cropping is good too.

[welshgirl15]

LEAST FAVOURITE:
#05: There too much of the pattern in the icon, it over powers the image itself

#03: The light texture takes over the icon, and you can't tell who it is in the icon. Also part of the text is difficult to read.

FAVOURITE:
#01: The angle of the image adds interest to the icon

#04: Beauliful colouring, especially of the dress