Taking the Initiative
anonymous
September 26 2011, 22:30:48 UTC
Excellent--dialogue, action, everything. Parts of the ending reminded me of "The Road," but people enslaving their own kind at the end of the world is pretty much what you'd expect to happen, no matter what story it is. My only question was the ending--why would Angel get happy finding out the apocalypse wasn't one event? I understand wanting to end the story before you get into the whole Buffy-finds-out-Angel-is-human thing but it confused me.
Good effort
anonymous
September 27 2011, 22:54:17 UTC
This story started off very strong - very good description of the devastation of an apocalypse.
Then around the middle it started to get confusing - I felt I was missing important information, as if it'd been removed - and by the end it felt rushed, as if the author had to wrap it up to keep within the page/character limit.
I was losing track of which demon was which and who was fighting which one.
I did, however, like Buffy's entrance and she was quite quippy.
The last line reminds me a lot of Xander's "Yeah, especially since Angel's back" line from the end of "Pangs." I can just see Buffy staring blankly at Zack as the camera fades to black.
first commenter: Angel got happy that the apocalypse didn't have just one cause because it wasn't all-his-fault. He'd been beating himself up since the fight and the end of the series. It was really more relief than actual happiness, but I think Buffy would respond with the line she did. Sorry if that wasn't clear. Thank you for the "excellent", and yeah, enslavement is kind of an obvious probability for a post-apocalyptic world; that's probably why I wanted to do it.
chrismarlowe, zanthinegirl: Thanks.
fourth commenter: Originally I imagined a much more complicated tale with a "cast of thousands" but knew that was beyond the scope of the contest, so I did pair it down considerably, but that was before I started writing. At any rate, that may be what you were sensing ... or missing. I wonder what the next scene would be.
Comments 6
All in all, a great read! Really, really good!
Reply
A pretty exciting story and I like the idea of the apocalypse not just being one event.
Reply
Reply
Then around the middle it started to get confusing - I felt I was missing important information, as if it'd been removed - and by the end it felt rushed, as if the author had to wrap it up to keep within the page/character limit.
I was losing track of which demon was which and who was fighting which one.
I did, however, like Buffy's entrance and she was quite quippy.
The last line reminds me a lot of Xander's "Yeah, especially since Angel's back" line from the end of "Pangs." I can just see Buffy staring blankly at Zack as the camera fades to black.
Reply
first commenter: Angel got happy that the apocalypse didn't have just one cause because it wasn't all-his-fault. He'd been beating himself up since the fight and the end of the series. It was really more relief than actual happiness, but I think Buffy would respond with the line she did.
Sorry if that wasn't clear.
Thank you for the "excellent", and yeah, enslavement is kind of an obvious probability for a post-apocalyptic world; that's probably why I wanted to do it.
chrismarlowe, zanthinegirl: Thanks.
fourth commenter: Originally I imagined a much more complicated tale with a "cast of thousands" but knew that was beyond the scope of the contest, so I did pair it down considerably, but that was before I started writing. At any rate, that may be what you were sensing ... or missing.
I wonder what the next scene would be.
Reply
And oop,s I thought Illyira was *one* of the slave traders at first. Liked what you did with her.
Multiple apocalypses is an interesting, and very plausible idea.
Reply
Leave a comment