Loved this one too! :D Is there anyway you can post the icon without the text?
1 Fav: 1- everything is off center and i love it! =D pretty colours are a plus 01- Love the bright coloring. The red text really draws out the hints of red within the icon. 01- vivid colors, great text placement and an interesting crop makes a gorgeous icon 1 - I love the crop on this icon, and the colours are very pretty. it's a nice change to see on a batlestar galactica icon and a different take on style. 1 - the cropping and text placement looks great, great colouring 1- Wonderful cropping, coloring, and lighting. Affects are well executed, and choice of font and textures is well done. 1- I probably would have liked this without the text, but I still ADORE this! The colorings are so bold in it and vibrant. The crop is excellent as well!
Constructive criticism: N/A
Best interpretation: N/A
Additional Comments: 01- Cool crop, and nice text use here. Nice coloring, also.
10 Fav: 10 - I really like the placement of the figure over the text and the fact rather than it being centered its off to one side. The colouring of the text also looks good.
Constructive criticism: 10- i like the subject being on the corner and the text in the back, but at first i thought you spelled DEY... if i never knew the fandom i'd say he was DEY or DEV. the back colour also is not related to the subject, i'd suggest a more lighter one to make him pop up as dark as he is 10- Great background change! But since Ronon's picture is dark with a dark background, it makes it hard to see him. I'd brightened him a little so we see him better.
Best interpretation: N/A
Additional Comments: 10- i like the idea of the icon, the text and the cut-out, but think the background color could be a bit more vibrant.
23 Fav: 23- Beautiful, stunning colors here! I like the use of texture and the way you've handled the negative space. 23- Perfect crop! The coloring is also really well done - I love the orange/cyan vibe this icon gives out. Also really interesting texture use, it only enhances the center of the focus. 23- The colors in this icon are beautiful! Everything is very balanced which makes the icon look good. And the texture in the background is a nice touch. 23- Great use of negative space. Nice clear coloring. 23 - The colouring is very well done. Its soft and delicate without being too washed out. 23- Gorgeous. Great coloring, great cropping--this icon has it all. 23- Gorgeous coloring on this, and I love how the focus seems to soften as you go further back from the figure.
Constructive criticism: 23- the figure and the background don't seem to relate to one another.
awwww, thank you for mod's choice =) i'd lieke to see if there are other feedback for this one was my fav of the set XD ahah! but still screened, please =)
Constructive criticism: 24- This icon is rather dark and the text placement is not very good, it kind of blends in with his nose. 24- More contrast on the subject would be nice. Right now more attention is given to the text which is difficult to read. 24- the text placement could have been modified a little bit so it doesn't touch the tip of the subject's nose. there's a nice atmosphere in the icon as a whole, though. 24- I like the idea and it’s a solid icon, but the text (while very beautiful) distracts too much because the subject is a little too dark. The text is over a light background and has a soft and light shadow to make it stand out, but the subject doesn’t really stand out next to it. Also, the positioning of the text with this kind of crop is a bit odd and it just adds more focus to the text instead of the subject and the text. You could crop the photo so the subject is further away and move him a little more towards the center and perhaps lower the text closer to his chest.
Comments 33
I'd love to see the feedback for #1 please, and unscreened is perfectly fine.
Reply
Reply
Reply
1
Fav:
1- everything is off center and i love it! =D pretty colours are a plus
01- Love the bright coloring. The red text really draws out the hints of red within the icon.
01- vivid colors, great text placement and an interesting crop makes a gorgeous icon
1 - I love the crop on this icon, and the colours are very pretty. it's a nice change to see on a batlestar galactica icon and a different take on style.
1 - the cropping and text placement looks great, great colouring
1- Wonderful cropping, coloring, and lighting. Affects are well executed, and choice of font and textures is well done.
1- I probably would have liked this without the text, but I still ADORE this! The colorings are so bold in it and vibrant. The crop is excellent as well!
Constructive criticism:
N/A
Best interpretation:
N/A
Additional Comments:
01- Cool crop, and nice text use here. Nice coloring, also.
Reply
Reply
Fav:
10 - I really like the placement of the figure over the text and the fact rather than it being centered its off to one side. The colouring of the text also looks good.
Constructive criticism:
10- i like the subject being on the corner and the text in the back, but at first i thought you spelled DEY... if i never knew the fandom i'd say he was DEY or DEV. the back colour also is not related to the subject, i'd suggest a more lighter one to make him pop up as dark as he is
10- Great background change! But since Ronon's picture is dark with a dark background, it makes it hard to see him. I'd brightened him a little so we see him better.
Best interpretation:
N/A
Additional Comments:
10- i like the idea of the icon, the text and the cut-out, but think the background color could be a bit more vibrant.
Reply
Reply
23
Fav:
23- Beautiful, stunning colors here! I like the use of texture and the way you've handled the negative space.
23- Perfect crop! The coloring is also really well done - I love the orange/cyan vibe this icon gives out. Also really interesting texture use, it only enhances the center of the focus.
23- The colors in this icon are beautiful! Everything is very balanced which makes the icon look good. And the texture in the background is a nice touch.
23- Great use of negative space. Nice clear coloring.
23 - The colouring is very well done. Its soft and delicate without being too washed out.
23- Gorgeous. Great coloring, great cropping--this icon has it all.
23- Gorgeous coloring on this, and I love how the focus seems to soften as you go further back from the figure.
Constructive criticism:
23- the figure and the background don't seem to relate to one another.
Best interpretation:
N/A
Additional Comments:
23 Gorgeous coloring!
Reply
Reply
Reply
Fav:
N/A
Constructive criticism:
24- This icon is rather dark and the text placement is not very good, it kind of blends in with his nose.
24- More contrast on the subject would be nice. Right now more attention is given to the text which is difficult to read.
24- the text placement could have been modified a little bit so it doesn't touch the tip of the subject's nose. there's a nice atmosphere in the icon as a whole, though.
24- I like the idea and it’s a solid icon, but the text (while very beautiful) distracts too much because the subject is a little too dark. The text is over a light background and has a soft and light shadow to make it stand out, but the subject doesn’t really stand out next to it. Also, the positioning of the text with this kind of crop is a bit odd and it just adds more focus to the text instead of the subject and the text. You could crop the photo so the subject is further away and move him a little more towards the center and perhaps lower the text closer to his chest.
Best interpretation:
N/A
( ... )
Reply
Leave a comment