Comments | sams1ra: Swan Song

sams1ra

Swan Song

May 14, 2010 17:07

( Thank you, Kripke and krew, for 5 great years! )

Comments 13

parisindy May 14 2010, 15:14:56 UTC

got agree this felt like a series finale not a season finale.. and i got to say i would have been okay with that

i live in fear of them 'ruining' it with more comedy and crap.

it was a brilliant episode.

sams1ra May 14 2010, 17:15:09 UTC

I have no idea what they're gonna do with season 6, and to tell you the truth, I have no faith in Sera Gamble.

parisindy May 14 2010, 18:21:15 UTC

i am more then nervous

sams1ra May 15 2010, 04:40:44 UTC

Me, too.

albeitslowly May 14 2010, 15:52:32 UTC

LOL. I guess we agree to disagree. Not gonna harsh on your squee.

sams1ra May 14 2010, 16:54:18 UTC

Sorry you didn't like it...
Haven't made up my mind about season 6 yet. I guess I'll keep on watching, but just to get my Dean fix.
Without Kripke... I have a feeling it'll turn out to be like the West Wing in its final seasons...

pippii May 14 2010, 16:44:29 UTC

That episode was just perfect, and I agree with you, even if I looks forward to season 6;) But I just want more Jared that`s why^^
♥hugs♥

sams1ra May 14 2010, 16:51:26 UTC

*sigh*
Yes, I'm not ready to give up my Dean fix just yet, either ^__~

pinkphoenix1985 May 15 2010, 09:11:31 UTC

I see your point of the episode being a series finale but still I didn't like most of this season--it was just a lot of fillers in my opinion

sams1ra May 15 2010, 17:17:15 UTC

I liked most of it. It had that season 1 feel again.

geckoholic May 17 2010, 20:45:35 UTC

Season 5 was fun. Period.
I am SO proud of you. ;)

Ah, in a way, it did feel like an ending. But still, I'm not willing to give up hope on S6 before it even that. Would I have done that mid-S4, when show didn't feel right for me, I would've missed SO MUCH. So, I'll stick with the boys. I hope you will, too!! ♥

sams1ra May 18 2010, 04:16:20 UTC

I agree, but on the other hand, we still had Kripke in season 5. And the knowledge that, for him, it was always a 5 year plan, so there was something to wait for.
Gamble, on the other hand, rarely wrote an episode I enjoyed, and never did so on her own, only as a co-writer.
*sigh*

geckoholic May 20 2010, 16:02:47 UTC

Well, I'm not exactly the president of Kripke's fanclub. My fav episode is one written by him, and I loved Swan Song, but some other episodes he wrote sucked ass, if you ask me (*cough* Heaven And Hell *cough*), while I liked several of Gamble's episodes, sooo . . . For now, I'm good with her taking the wheel.