Leave a comment

Comments 10

obsessive24 January 5 2009, 23:33:32 UTC
I love this vid. Lots and lots and lots and lots of love. First, I love the film and the book, and I love Tom McRae too like whoa, and I love *your* work, so even before I downloaded the vid I knew this was going to be good ( ... )

Reply

saltwatergirl January 6 2009, 13:42:25 UTC
WOW. I don't know what to say. I'm a sucker for tragic epics that leave me in tears. Thank you so much for the lovely feedback it was wonderful to read and it's really thoughtful of you to take the time to go it to detail. :)

Reply


milly January 6 2009, 01:43:26 UTC
That was simply stunning, and mesmerizing. The water imagery through it all and the emotional punch of the parallels was just beautiful. The waves intercut with the blanket being drawn over Robbie's body was probably my favorite part, but the whole is really just amazing.

Reply

saltwatergirl January 6 2009, 13:43:23 UTC
When I saw that in the movie I thought to myself: they both laid down and never got up again, it just so sad.And thank you for the lovely feedback! :)

Reply


winterevanesce January 6 2009, 05:26:31 UTC
That was absolutely stunning! I love Tom Mcrae and Atonement <3!

Reply

saltwatergirl January 6 2009, 13:44:04 UTC
Irish guys with gorgeous voices (Tom McRae, David Gray and Damien Rice) make WONDERFUL MUSIC. :) Thank you so much for the feedback!

Reply


charmax January 6 2009, 07:12:21 UTC
what a breathtakingly beautiful and emotionally powerful vid! Fantastic!

Reply

saltwatergirl January 6 2009, 13:46:44 UTC
Thank you so much for the feedback. I'm so glad that you enjoyed it! :)

Reply


tearful_eye January 7 2009, 22:13:25 UTC
oh wow. this is so beautifully heartbreaking, i really love it!

Reply

saltwatergirl January 8 2009, 17:12:07 UTC
Thank you so much!!! :)

Reply


Leave a comment

Up