Leave a comment

Comments 41

melwicker June 22 2008, 19:21:37 UTC
NOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!! I didn't want the Doctor to die and this makes it feel even sadder.

Reply

rude_not_ginger June 22 2008, 20:26:49 UTC
I could see Donna being the only thing that saved him in that scene. It was tragic, but not permanent! (as if anything in DW is!)

Reply


sinister_charm June 22 2008, 19:33:12 UTC
Very nice.

Reply

rude_not_ginger June 22 2008, 20:27:26 UTC
Thank you!

Reply

sinister_charm June 22 2008, 21:20:17 UTC
You're most welcome!

I felt that the whole dying bit needed a better explanation (I... admit, I was let down by 'it happened too quick for him to regenerate'), and you did it wonderfully.

Reply


brigadiertardis June 22 2008, 20:19:55 UTC
This made me wibble and the muse flailed a bit, too. Very beautiful.

Reply

rude_not_ginger June 22 2008, 20:28:02 UTC
Really, the real victim in this episode is the TARDIS. Am I the only one who nearly cried at seeing her all cannibalized like that? And dying! But being so strong!

Reply

brigadiertardis June 22 2008, 20:31:05 UTC
Ohgosh, I know. I got all flaily and teary-eyed and was all TARDIS!! and yeah. When they went inside and she was all dark and cold looking? Most emotional part of the episode for me. I swear, I've an unhealthy attachment to her. I want to write something up for it, because exploring why she kept fighting to stay alive all that time intrigues me.

Reply

sinister_charm June 22 2008, 21:00:31 UTC
You aren't the only one. Well, I wasn't so much 'crying' as 'rampaging anger', but I believe the intensity and the basic thought is still the same. :P

Reply


missbadwolf June 22 2008, 20:54:38 UTC
Oh gosh that was so sad :(

Reply

rude_not_ginger June 23 2008, 01:52:52 UTC
<3<3

Reply


hofficoffi June 22 2008, 21:15:10 UTC
I love that you can manage such a beautiful response to an episode that barely even featured the Doctor.

(And Lucy? Love it.)

Reply

rude_not_ginger June 23 2008, 01:53:30 UTC
Thank you so much! And as long as Saxon isn't coming back to destroy her life a different way...might as well give her another reason to suffer! MUWHAHAHAHAHAHA

Reply

hofficoffi June 23 2008, 02:02:59 UTC
<3! And I particularly liked it because it continues the episode's pattern of vaguely gratuitous name-dropping!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up