FRANCHISE RANKING: The "STAR WARS" Movies

[rpowell]

Comments

[calenfalathiel]

what an interesting ranking! it's a little different from most Star Wars fans it seems (but then again, mine is TOTALLY different from most SW fans). My ranking is as follows:
1. Revenge of the Sith
2. Return of the Jedi
3. Attack of the Clones (TIE)
3. Empire Strikes Back (TIE)
4. Phantom Menace (TIE)
4. A New Hope (TIE)

[rpowell]

That is different. It is very refreshing to meet someone whose taste in STAR WARS films is different from most people.

[michiru42]

Nifty! I'm way late, but thought I'd check in:

1) Episode II, Attack of the Clones: It's everything I'm interested in, politics and characterization, with action scenes used to bolster both rather than just...being there so we can see people hit each other.

2) Episode VI, Return of the Jedi: Luke and his father reuniting, Leia kicking butt, the Emperor being truly creepy for the first time. All the scenes just worked.

3) Episode III, Return of the Sith: The tragedy was breathtaking, even if we did know it would be all right in the end.

4) TIE: Episodes IV and V, A New Hope and The Empire Strikes Back. Good, entertaining movies, always worth watching.

5) Episode I, The Phantom Menace. A lot I didn't like about this one, which docks it from the others, but it still had some great moments.

[june7rose]

You and movie critics both agree about Empire being the best but for me, I say ROTS, it's certainly the most adult film of the six.

I would say:

1 -- ROTS
2 -- A New Hope
3 -- ESB
4 -- AOTC
5 -- ROTJ
6 -- Phantom Meanace, man that was bad, LOL. The entire movie is good for only one line: "Anakin Skywalker, meet Obi-Wan Kenobi." LOL