Aida - sexing up Opera and pseudo Marxist interpretations.

Jun 04, 2010 21:55

BBC4 7.30pm. Verdi imbued his work with a quintessentially 19th century theme. Copied by Gilbert & Sullivan (in The Sorcerer) the eponymous heroine of Aida is a slave but in fact (of course) secretly the daughter of the King of Ethiopia. Hidden class and the empire building of Egypt and England or Italy. Tonight the use of quasi modern costume ( Read more... )

britain, independent minds, entertainment, television, review

Leave a comment

Comments 15

But It's an opera about racism and imperialism neilmcg June 4 2010, 22:13:48 UTC

Aida is Ethiopian - she's black. But he's an arabian military hero, and he loves her despite her being black, and a political hostage. And that sends Amneris insane with jealousy... that he'd prefer a black slave, to an Egyptian Princess.

Early sketches show that Verdi originally intended to call it "Amneris", but changed his mind... so we have an Egyptian opera, named after an Ethiopian slave.

Powerful stuff indeed. At the heart of all that awesome hill of beans, there's the story of just three little people.

Reply


You haven't seen AIDA until you've seen Dmitry Bertmann's Helikon-Opera production neilmcg June 4 2010, 22:19:45 UTC

The Grand March staged with a small troop of 8-year-old boys, joyously given a Hitler Salute to the Pharoah.

This is a story for all time. Shortly before I emigrated to Moscow, I was at a funny and packed birthday party somewhere in North London, with a mixed group of Brits and various E European friends. Someone wanted to see the footy results, so the tv was briefly turned-on... and we astounded to see coverage of the RAF bombing Belgrade. "Give it those bastards!" cheered one bloke amongst those gathered. In the kitchen there was a Serbian girl in unstoppable hysterical screaming.

That's the story of AIDA.

Reply

Re: You haven't seen AIDA until you've seen Dmitry Bertmann's Helikon-Opera production ron_broxted June 5 2010, 09:20:03 UTC
Serbia is far from blameless about what happened. (Are you supporting them for the World Cup?)

Reply

Re: You haven't seen AIDA until you've seen Dmitry Bertmann's Helikon-Opera production neilmcg June 5 2010, 18:11:45 UTC

Oh dear, you've entirely missed the point, haven't you?

AIDA is about the civilians who get caught up in the war atrocities of others.

Massacring a country's utterly blameless civilians for the alleged crimes of their leaders is the act of a nation of gutless w*nkers. The train on the bridge was the point when Britain signed-up to yankee thuggery. But it provided Slick Willy with a way to avoid testimonial in the blowjob case, didn't it? And that was the REAL point of the yankee invasion.

Reply

Re: You haven't seen AIDA until you've seen Dmitry Bertmann's Helikon-Opera production ron_broxted June 5 2010, 20:12:51 UTC
Yes it seems I have missed the point. Serbs butchered Croats (who had also been killing Serbs). My reading of the bombing of Serbia is not that it was to provide a distraction for Clinton (who is highly regarded in Ulster). Accidental hitting of Chinese Embassy? Oops, Peking. Finally, I have been told I am OK to enter the U.A and A. (Transit only).

Reply


Good luck to the Rachel Corrie bob_idle June 5 2010, 07:50:55 UTC
I hope you will continue your live journal.
We can still read and comment - don't need to have Independent Minds.
Am going away for a while but will read and comment on your journal when I return (if possible).

bob

Reply

Re: Good luck to the Rachel Corrie ron_broxted June 5 2010, 09:20:43 UTC
Hope you have a nice trip, trying to set up links so that any and all can follow.

Reply


Not going!? oldgittom June 5 2010, 08:10:54 UTC
Mr Broxted,
whatever furniture-shuffling happens, please keep in touch with your comments, even tho occasionally obscure & baffling. At least yours are interesting, in contrast to The Toul, a bore's bore, an unflagging fount of what Dennis Healey used to call "Geriatric shoe repair operatives".

What's his secret? Is he free/extremely cheap? Got some intimate snaps of the owner? Like a perpetual motion machine, cannot be turned off? Is he a 69 degree High Mekon of the Bilderberg coven? Whichever, something should be done.

Reply

Re: Not going!? porkfright June 5 2010, 08:23:41 UTC
Yes, Ron-many of us will be pleased to hear anything you have to say. Independent Minds? As a fully paid up conspiracy theorist I am not surprised the goalposts are moving. Hear from you soon.

Reply

Re: Not going!? ron_broxted June 5 2010, 09:24:54 UTC
I have a few blogs up my sleeve, one is the Live Journal I had before this one. I shall blow the cobwebs off. Also my great unfinished novel and sundry blogs on Blogspot. Conspiracy? Hmmm... I received a short "Thank you for all your contributions" (beats Die scum die anyway;) but no notice as to when they will actually shut here.

Reply

Re: Not going!? ron_broxted June 5 2010, 09:22:49 UTC
Poor John Boy, don't be too hard on him. If someone came up to you with a wheelbarrow full of cash wouldn't you shill for them?

Reply


Leave a comment

Up