Comments | robinsociety: Favorite Robin episodes

railise in robinsociety

Favorite Robin episodes

Dec 11, 2009 19:30

Our Book of Blood discussion was fantastic!! But seeing as how this is the Robin Appreciation Society and all, I thought it'd be nice to discuss some RH episodes. ;) I thought that, perhaps, a good way to get started is to find out which episodes are everyone's favorites for Robin-related reasons. For example, my favorite episode is 1x13, since ( Read more... )

discussion, berserker!robs, poll

Comments 12

railise December 12 2009, 18:52:15 UTC

I actually had a tough time picking, too. While 1x13 wins my love for all the reasons I gave in the post, I adore most of the first two seasons. 1x08 is a really close runner-up for my affections-- we don't usually get to see Robin's dark side like that, but of the times we have, that's been the most frightening, I think. (In a good way.) And the fight with him and Guy is just UNF; along with the 3x11 tavern scene, that's my favorite scene between the two of them. And his conversation with Marian, when he's leaning against the tree, is just an excellent scene; very well done ( ... )

(The comment has been removed)

railise December 14 2009, 00:13:00 UTC

my favorite couple was about to get married. HOW COULD I NOT BE HAPPY??
Boy, they really screwed ALL of us over, didn't they? G/M'ers had an interrupted, never-to-be-repeated wedding; R/M'ers got two "weddings," neither a proper affair and the second one not only redundant, but with the bride gacking it at the end. WTF, show??? >:S

*ahem* Anyway. :D

All of his taunting of Allan in season 2, when he's suspecting Allan, are great.
Yes, absolutely. The fight scene between the two of them in the dungeon kitchens is superb, and all of their interactions are just heartbreaking.

I only heard it before in reference to season 2.See, I adore him in S1 and 2, and of course I still do in S3, but there were so many actions and lines scattered about which made me cringe, that I couldn't figure out what the writers were thinking. (Well, EVER, in S3, but still.) Even my husband, who did not have the investment in Robin that I did ;), remarked on a few of them. Thing is, it wasn't just Robin; they did a fine job of character assassination on ( ... )

railise December 15 2009, 22:33:34 UTC

Just a note that I'm going to leave this open for a little bit; I suspect that discussion will get going after the holidays, but this way we'll have the best idea of where to go with it. :)

ladyarcherfan3 February 7 2010, 20:52:49 UTC

Coming the party a bit late, but I figured late is better than never ( ... )