Leave a comment

Comments 21

joe_pike_junior July 22 2009, 01:38:01 UTC
I really like this. James supports Peter in the original story, but you've extended that metaphor in a wonderful way -- Peter helps Wilson to stay afloat, even when he's foundering and confused, heaving up bitter grief.

Well done.

Reply

shara_i July 27 2009, 03:39:10 UTC
Thank you! I loved the metaphor of floating Mer used in the original to juxtapose the past and present and I wasn't sure if looking at it literally would take away from it, but I'm glad it worked for you. :)

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

shara_i July 27 2009, 03:48:24 UTC
Thank you! I loved the way Mer showed the bond between Peter and James in the original fic and wanted to focus on that. The subtle way she described the weight of Wilson's grief was what inspired his silence here. I'm glad you like it!

Reply


jotc July 28 2009, 04:30:31 UTC
This was beautiful. I love the original, and the remix also. One little thing I liked because it added so much realism - Peter's first thought was that something happened to his father. That would be the natural assumption on getting an unexpected "bad news" call. I also liked Peter's hesitation and uncertainty on how to approach his brother - another thing that's very true to life.

Reply

shara_i July 29 2009, 22:12:54 UTC
Thank you! I debated taking that line out because it didn't really add to the theme or plot much, but it seemed to me to be the natural reaction that Peter would have, so I left it in. I'm glad you liked it!

Reply


photoash July 28 2009, 07:55:12 UTC
Lovely remix to a great story :) I like how you flipped perspectives you did a great job with Peter!

Reply

shara_i July 29 2009, 22:13:33 UTC
Thank you! I'm glad you liked Peter here :)

Reply


hannahrorlove July 29 2009, 01:47:02 UTC
I love the sense of confinement in this - living in the same old house, the inability to verbalize inner thoughts - and how that breaks in the last two sections, when they finally run out to sea. It's a really nice way to show what water means to both James and Peter, and also to communicate the characters' desire to break free of their present lives.

Reply

shara_i July 29 2009, 22:16:42 UTC
Thank you! That was really what I was trying to convey, with Peter's desire to go back to the simpler (at least for him) and safer role he held in his childhood, and how both he and James are, in a way, trapped in their lives here.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up