Comments | remixredux08: Of Horn and Ivory (The Dream Is a Wish Remix) [Harry Potter; Minerva McGonagall & Harry Potter]

jimnpam in remixredux08

Of Horn and Ivory (The Dream Is a Wish Remix) [Harry Potter; Minerva McGonagall & Harry Potter]

Apr 12, 2008 16:19

Title: Of Horn and Ivory (The Dream Is a Wish Remix)
Author: sambethe
Summary: It might not have been as anyone dreamt.
Rating: G
Fandom: Harry Potter
Warnings: None
Spoilers: Through Deathly Hallows.
Title, Author and URL of original story: She Sees Harry Potter in Her Dreams, missparker
Notes: Thanks go to magnetic_pole, rufus, and mindabbles for the beta work and advice.

( Of Horn and Ivory )

character: harry potter, fandom: harry potter, original author: missparker, rating: g, remix author: sambethe, character: minerva mcgonagall

Comments 8

missparker April 19 2008, 23:37:05 UTC

i just love this. love this. you really went above and beyond. i love the back story, i love the twists and turns you took to make it canon compliant. i think you kept mcgonagall's no nonsense voice well while still letting her softer side shine through. the detail of lily giving birth at her house was so imaginative, it really tied mcgonagall to the story in a way that mine didn't quite capture.

i like how harry's letter changed, how he sent her small gifts. it was beautiful. thank you so, so much.

sambethe April 27 2008, 23:47:54 UTC

I'm really pleased you enjoyed this and that McGonagall worked for you. It is always good to know the original author isn't horrified. :)

I enjoyed getting to play around with your story.

such_heights April 20 2008, 18:38:10 UTC

Oh, fantastic! I love the way you've fleshed out her relationships with Harry and with others, and this is full of light touches that really brings the whole thing to life. I very much enjoyed this! And, hmm, I also have suspicions about its authorship.

sambethe April 27 2008, 23:48:48 UTC

Like I said, complete pants at anonymity.

I am glad you enjoyed.

Cheers!

mindabbles April 25 2008, 04:14:26 UTC

This is beautiful. I really love the way you develop the relationship from the very moment of his birth until adulthood. There are so many wonderful details in this. Lovely!

sambethe April 27 2008, 23:49:28 UTC

Thanks (especially for helping out with the beta work).

I'm glad you enjoyed. :)

entrenous88 April 27 2008, 10:47:19 UTC

This was lovely! The way Minerva experienced the major events and witnessed smaller emblematic exchanges between the characters was incredibly touching. I really enjoyed this.

sambethe April 27 2008, 23:51:04 UTC

I'm so pleased you enjoyed.

Cheers! :)