Question for flisters

Dec 01, 2009 10:44

Not my F!S:

Read more... )

kirk/spock, f!s, star trek, spock/uhura

Leave a comment

Comments 10

ennyousai December 1 2009, 15:56:12 UTC
I don't think it should be *only* K/S. I mean, the term wasn't invented by Spock specifically to use for Kirk, so...

I also don't see why I can't be used for girl/girl or S/U. Or any other Vulcan/human Vulcan/Vulcan relationship, for that matter.

Ah, fandom. *munches popcorn*

BTW, do you and Pacabel want company at some point this weekend, mayhap?

Reply

remadi December 1 2009, 16:19:40 UTC
I realize that Gene Roddenberry made up the term specifically to describe K/S, but is a Vulcan word that had been around long before Kirk or Spock were ever born.

I've always taken 'brother' as a generic term, used for brother or sister (like using 'he' to refer to 'he or she',) and so I see t'hy'la, as a word that can be used for pretty much any gender pairing.

Pacabel and I would love company this weekend. Anytime is good for us, just let me know. :)

Reply

ennyousai December 3 2009, 23:15:18 UTC
Well, I'm downtown covering a lunch shift this Saturday afternoon, so I could head up your way after that?

Reply

remadi December 3 2009, 23:36:46 UTC
That sounds good. Just call/text me when you're on your way. :)

Reply


damalur December 1 2009, 16:42:33 UTC
Not gonna lie, it seems strange to me to see the term applied to a m/f relationship, but I've been knocking around the Trek slash fandom for a while. I'm not bothered by it, though - I just wonder if there isn't a better term to use, like adun/aduna.

Reply

remadi December 1 2009, 17:02:35 UTC
I agree with using better terms. Although I do think it can apply to m/f relationships as well as m/m, I do think that it is a very unique term that shouldn't be used lightly. Especially in nu!Trek fics, I think people tend use the term too easily and too early in their relationship (S/U, K/S, whoever.)

Reply

damalur December 1 2009, 17:09:10 UTC
I do think it can apply to all sorts of relationships - the concept of "brotherhood," for lack of a better term, transcends gender. I agree that people would build the relationships between their characters more; Spock's not gonna be calling Kirk (or Uhura!) "t'hy'la" for a good five or ten years, maybe more. It's the history between the two that gives the term its weight

Reply

remadi December 1 2009, 17:23:32 UTC
Exactly. :)

And that icon always makes me smile.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up