Leave a comment

Comments 101

elucidate_this January 13 2008, 23:26:49 UTC
lady, i love this, which you already knew. i'm so glad you posted it! mostly because you need to hear that other people think it's awesome too! and because i can finally start telling people to read it :)

Reply

redbrickrose January 13 2008, 23:28:21 UTC
♥ ♥ ♥ Thank you, sweetie. And I owe a lot of it to you.

Reply


offtheceiling January 13 2008, 23:36:31 UTC
Oh, wow. This is beautiful and aching and sharp. *hands* I don't even know what else to say. I love it.

Reply

redbrickrose January 14 2008, 00:04:27 UTC
Thank you so much!

Reply


disarm_d January 13 2008, 23:52:16 UTC
!!!

When I started reading this, I thought to myself that I should probably open up a comment window so that I could paste in all the ridiculously out-of-this-world amazing lines as I was reading. But then, I got so completely enthralled in the story, I didn't actually do it.

This was just ridiculously gorgeous and I'm all stunned and incoherent right now, but here I go trying to comment anyway.

All of your characterizations were perfect. Ryan as a character doesn't normally have the same draw for me that some of the others do, but in this? I was captivated and in love with him. I think you had the most amazing balance of edges and sweetness with Brendon. Spencer, oh my god, Spencer, just killed me dead, every time he was in a scene, and Jon was just amazing ( ... )

Reply

redbrickrose January 14 2008, 00:06:30 UTC
Oh, wow. I really appreciate the in-depth feedback. (And that Ryan worked for you here if he isn't always your favorite). Thanks so much!

Reply


harriet_vane January 14 2008, 00:07:16 UTC
I love this! Your Ryan voice is really great, and I loved his descriptions of Brendon -- they felt totally true and real. (I clicked on neverneverfic's rec, too.)

Reply

redbrickrose January 14 2008, 00:09:46 UTC
Thanks! I'm glad you liked it!

Reply


warmingweather January 14 2008, 00:13:23 UTC
Oh, oh, oh. This was absolutely wonderful. I loved your look into Ryan's headspace and I loved the push-pull and the dynamics between him and Brendon. The scene with "I Never' was so perfectly overwhelming. This was an absolute joy to read, and I'll be thinking about it for some time.

Reply

redbrickrose January 15 2008, 00:55:32 UTC
Thank you so much! I'm really glad you enjoyed it. :)

Reply


Leave a comment

Up