WOW. ♥ my favurites: angry, funny, large text, numbers, the rainbow one (perfect fit! OMG!) star & weird!
Your category choice, the one I find weakest is #2 'cause I find that 'diagonal' cut a bit weird and thus it shocked me and puzzled me. , favs of it are 5 & then the rest 'cause I can't pick just one.
your ac I also like , I think my favourite is number 2, I liked the crops of 1&3, not your 'typical' cropping but they totally work
rejects... it's a shame there was not 22 icons so you could fit #2 & #3 'cause wow! amazing crop on #3, I would have never dared to do it but it totally works (or so I think). Seriously I don't see why you don't like your own text, I love it.
It's interesting that you don't like #2 of the text ones, because that one is one of my favorites. It's weird how no one likes my favorite icons, but everyone loves my least favorite ones. *is confused* I really hate 2 & 3 of the rejects, which is why I didn't put them in.
I tried really hard to experiment with different styles in this batch, so I hope I did okay. I doubt I'll win anything.
Again, thanks for the feedback. I really appreciate it. =D
I <3 YOU FOR THE FEEDBACK! =) wait, why do you justify your love of me? You can simply love me for myself, I accept that! >;)
not about not liking but about finding it as the weakest link, not really the same. I think it's the sharp cut it kind of drew my eyes away from the font, if the cut among both images was a bit blurred it would be perfect (imo) but if you look at my icons more and more I tend to blur the lines if I use more than one image in it because it's how my psyche works. Also in that gandalf/animal icon? I loved it, it didn't have text to 'fight' for attention of that cut XD but if you look at my icons it's not like I'm an expert at getting icons right I tend to lean always to one style XD
I really hate 2 & 3 of the rejects, which is why I didn't put them in. And I accept that I just wish the category was 7 icons long so we could have had those 2 too, since I personally liked them too.
I tried really hard to experiment with different styles in this batch, so I hope I did okay. I doubt I'll win anything. I fail at
( ... )
I fail at that, so hard, I just will try and then will fail 'cause I end up hating those icons or thinking they're not good enough so I nix them.
That happens to me a lot. I just looked at my icons and noticed that a lot of them looked all the same, and I saw that other people's submissions had more variation to them. For example, look at my last entry to lotr20in20. There isn't really much variation to the style or the crop. I have several Uther icons that I made for this that I didn't even bother to include in the rejects because I hated them so much. I just ended up looking at past submissions for style ideas. I got the diagonal crop idea from last round's 'amused' winner. I still have a lot of trouble with text, though.
Comments 12
Reply
Reply
Reply
I was cracking up when I was making the Funny one.
Reply
Your category choice, the one I find weakest is #2 'cause I find that 'diagonal' cut a bit weird and thus it shocked me and puzzled me. , favs of it are 5 & then the rest 'cause I can't pick just one.
your ac I also like , I think my favourite is number 2, I liked the crops of 1&3, not your 'typical' cropping but they totally work
rejects... it's a shame there was not 22 icons so you could fit #2 & #3 'cause wow! amazing crop on #3, I would have never dared to do it but it totally works (or so I think). Seriously I don't see why you don't like your own text, I love it.
Reply
It's interesting that you don't like #2 of the text ones, because that one is one of my favorites. It's weird how no one likes my favorite icons, but everyone loves my least favorite ones. *is confused*
I really hate 2 & 3 of the rejects, which is why I didn't put them in.
I tried really hard to experiment with different styles in this batch, so I hope I did okay. I doubt I'll win anything.
Again, thanks for the feedback. I really appreciate it. =D
Reply
wait, why do you justify your love of me? You can simply love me for myself, I accept that! >;)
not about not liking but about finding it as the weakest link, not really the same. I think it's the sharp cut it kind of drew my eyes away from the font, if the cut among both images was a bit blurred it would be perfect (imo) but if you look at my icons more and more I tend to blur the lines if I use more than one image in it because it's how my psyche works. Also in that gandalf/animal icon? I loved it, it didn't have text to 'fight' for attention of that cut XD but if you look at my icons it's not like I'm an expert at getting icons right I tend to lean always to one style XD
I really hate 2 & 3 of the rejects, which is why I didn't put them in.
And I accept that I just wish the category was 7 icons long so we could have had those 2 too, since I personally liked them too.
I tried really hard to experiment with different styles in this batch, so I hope I did okay. I doubt I'll win anything. I fail at ( ... )
Reply
That happens to me a lot. I just looked at my icons and noticed that a lot of them looked all the same, and I saw that other people's submissions had more variation to them. For example, look at my last entry to lotr20in20. There isn't really much variation to the style or the crop. I have several Uther icons that I made for this that I didn't even bother to include in the rejects because I hated them so much. I just ended up looking at past submissions for style ideas. I got the diagonal crop idea from last round's 'amused' winner. I still have a lot of trouble with text, though.
Reply
Reply
Reply
I guess I'm only snagging the "Pimp" one, then. Will credit.
Reply
Leave a comment