This is the question and answer post for rarewomen 2014. General questions can go right in the comments and one of us will get back to you as soon as possible
( Read more... )
Aurora (Once Upon a Time) is coming up as ineligible on the nomination form. I get 255 works >1000 words on AO3, and 207 on FF.net. AO3 is way under the cutoff, and FF.net just barely over, but so borderline I feel she should probably still be eligible? (If necessary, I could probably go through and pull out seven fics that aren't actually about her, but I'd rather not unless I have to.)
Hi! The profile information for the parent collection Rarewomen still has the dates and discontinued fandom restrictions from 2012, so the 2014 subcollection has those in the profile as well.
I'm going through the nominated characters and I've noticed at least two characters on there who don't belong: Xavin (under Runaways (Comics))), and Inukashi (under No. 6 - All Media Types). Neither of these characters have self-identified as women; they are frequently gendered as such by fandom, but in their respective canons they refuse to self-identify with a binary gender, and as the rules state, If the character actively refuses to self-identify with a gender, we will not arbitrarily assign them one. That character is ineligible.
Is it possible at this point to make these characters ineligible? As a non-binary person, it's honestly pretty upsetting to see two examples of the closest thing I have to non-binary representation gendered as women for a challenge.
My apologies for not seeing that Xavin had been discussed already - I'm usually more thorough in checking out previous discussion than that! Thank you for your reply.
Comments 27
Elementary has Joan Watson
Sherlock has Mary Watson
But Mary was named in the Elementary nom - it's likely to confuse writers; it certainly did me.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
(The comment has been removed)
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Is it possible at this point to make these characters ineligible? As a non-binary person, it's honestly pretty upsetting to see two examples of the closest thing I have to non-binary representation gendered as women for a challenge.
Reply
(The comment has been removed)
Reply
Leave a comment