Nomination Debates - Updated 13/07/17

[rc_mod]

Thanks for all your nominations so far

Comments

Thundercats

[sirvalkyrie]

Leo and Panthera are different characters.

http://thundercats.wikia.com/wiki/Leo
http://thundercats.wikia.com/wiki/Panthera

Re: Thundercats

[rc_mod]

Thank you!

[haploidsock]

FYI these characters are in the wrong fandom. Currently listed under Puella Magi Madoka Magica:
Anri Airi
Chitose Yuma
Kure Kirika
Mikuni Oriko

They are actually from the spinoff series Puella Magi Oriko Magica and Puella Magi Kazumi Magica.

[rc_mod]

Thanks for pointing that out. They were nominated under the Madoka Magica fandom and available as tags in that fandom, so we didn't notice.

[sirvalkyrie]

I nominated them, but I nominated it as "Madoka Magica and Related Fandoms". I don't know why it was changed to the anime fandom.

There is a lot of crossover of the anime characters into Oriko Magica and Kazumi Magica.

[trobadora]

Terminator: the Sarah Connor Chronicles
Cameron (338 out of 692 on ff.net)

Ah, I see, I was only looking at AO3, where she has 106 stories.

[snickfic]

FYI, I think the following are ineligibe:
Faith Lehane (983 qualifying stories on AO3 out of 8024 BtVS stories)
Clint Barton (544 out of 3485)

[rc_mod]

I have 756 out of 7500 fics on AO3 for Faith, but you're right, they're still ineglible. Maybe that's because she has been approved for Angel: the Series?

The same goes for Barton, as we have several Marvel fandoms.

Thank you for letting us know! We'll try to find a way to work around that.

[3am_moonlight]

Faith is ineglible in both Buffy and Angel since she's listed in more than 250 fics in both.

Also, Alonna Gunn never appeared on BtVS so she's ineglible for that show.

[rc_mod]

Actually, when we checked, Faith (Angel) managed to just slip in with 250 fics. Now there are 251 and we don't want to make a fuss because there's a high probability one of those 251 fics doesn't focus primarily on her.

Anyway, thank you for bringing Alonna to our attention!