Leave a comment

Comments 53

tool_of_satan September 8 2010, 16:32:15 UTC
OK, you sold me.

ISFDB says that there is also a collection of stories set in the same world, Blood and Ivory.

Reply

jinian September 8 2010, 17:00:16 UTC
If you can cope with extremely poor copyediting, you may wish to read that collection. I couldn't finish it.

Reply

tool_of_satan September 8 2010, 17:02:32 UTC
Yeah, I hear Meisha Merlin's copyediting was terrible (there was an earlier, shorter edition from Hypatia, which might be better). It's a moot point since copies appear to be unobtainable for less than $50 and my library system doesn't have it.

Reply

jonquil September 8 2010, 17:07:55 UTC
It's really ironic that MM's crappily-produced books are now Valuable Collectors' Items. Fortunately both Hodgell and the Liaden books are being republished at Baen.

Reply


My comments over at DW jonquil September 8 2010, 17:06:16 UTC

thomasyan September 8 2010, 17:59:45 UTC
I posted briefly about the 5th book: http://thomasyan.livejournal.com/345457.html

One thing I said was: I don't know exactly why, but I don't care so much about Tori. In all the books, I generally want his sections to be over so that we get back to Jame. I think I'm more curious abuot Yce than I am about Tori.

Reply

chomiji September 8 2010, 21:50:51 UTC


I often want to smack Tori in the head and tell him to get a clue. Also, I love Hodgell, but romantic passion is not her strong suit.

Reply

jonquil September 8 2010, 22:04:01 UTC
Given the societal setup in the book, who's involved in a romance? The only genuine romances I've seen are between women and their sister-kin. Also, it's pretty clear where Jame is headed, marriage-wise if not entirely romantically.

It just doesn't seem to be a society with any emphasis on romantic love as such; sex, yes, affection, yes, but deep love seems to be reserved for kin.

Reply

estara September 8 2010, 22:33:08 UTC
This!

Reply


thecityofdis September 8 2010, 18:36:17 UTC
I definitely want to read this now.

Reply


wiredwizard September 8 2010, 18:55:35 UTC
God Stalk I really loved. The rest... =shrug= not so much. The anthology I'll get when I can get it at an affordable price if only to be able to mark the series as complete in the book cataloguing software.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up