One man's bloop is another man's gleep

Oct 09, 2007 11:14

Has the phrase "freedom fighters" been used non-ironically anywhere in the western world at any time in the last 25 years?

No?

OK, then stop implying that your political opponents are using the term in order to equivocate their positions. Thank you.

language, politics

Leave a comment

Comments 5

novalis October 9 2007, 15:31:26 UTC
Yes.

(that's a t-shirt that FSF Europe sells)

Reply


doctor_atomic October 9 2007, 17:08:05 UTC
That term is used in many a reggae song.

Reply


rserocki October 9 2007, 17:09:25 UTC
I read it used in a non-ironic sense when someone said he didn't like how the pirates in PotC 3 were shown as being freedom fighters when they were more bloodthirsty and such in the first movie. Although I recognize this is not real world.

Reply


radtea October 9 2007, 19:11:39 UTC
Yes, but only by bellicose conservatives in support of rightist thugs, particularly in Central America and specifically in Nicaragua in the '80's.

"Freedom fighter" is as silly a term as "terrorist". One identifies the group by its nominal goal, the other by its purported method. Neither is useful for distinguishing anything from anything else. I'm damned sure the non-violent Buddhist monks in Burma have the junta there in a state of terror: you don't send out the army to violently suppress and kill people who don't make you piss yourself with abject fear.

Likewise, the Taliban are fighting for the freedom to impose Islamic law on a particular hunk of geography, and the Zionists who fought for the creation of Israel were pretty keen on having the freedom to create a Jewish state.

But I do think the use of anything other than neutral descriptive terms ("irregular fighters", "guerilla fighters", etc.) by anyone over the age of forty is grounds for dismissing their opinion on the matter entirely.

Reply


What Is Proactol anonymous March 11 2008, 14:41:32 UTC
Thanks for very interesting article. btw. I really enjoyed reading all of your posts. It’s interesting to read ideas, and observations from someone else’s point of view… makes you think more.
So please keep up the great work. Greetings.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up