Comments | pottersues: 0148: Sweets for my Sweet Sherbert

pottersues

0148: Sweets for my Sweet Sherbert - Minerva McGonagall

Aug 30, 2003 21:02

NOTE TO SELF: stop sending the victims readers on sue-venger hunts. You always regret it.

TITLE: Sweets for my Sweet Sherbert Lemon'
PERPETRATOR: minervarette

SUE-O-METER:

( Read more... )

p - sue what plot? swp, rating - toxic, sue - minerva mcgonagal

Comments 47

eljuno August 31 2003, 03:21:07 UTC

Oh dear sweet holy lord.

Thank you. This has officially been the most frightening day of my life, and that just added to it.

*shiver*

*shivershiver*

*snickering* anonymous August 31 2003, 03:23:04 UTC

*is snickering hysterically*
Never mind he's over 150 and she's just in her 70s
(ugh - please for all that is holy - don't let them reproduce!!)

Re: *snickering* anonymous September 1 2003, 16:29:24 UTC

Oh God, and 80 year age difference! Who cares if they're old people; what's gross is that Mcgonnagal kissed a man old enough to be her great-great-grandfather!

bruisedgarden August 31 2003, 03:57:21 UTC

Er... there really are no words.

Kind of reminds me of my parents getting back from their second honeymoon and my mom continually saying "Hot monkey sex!" when she walks into the room to embarass my father and bother me.

... Rather does remind me of that.

queen_kiwi August 31 2003, 04:04:07 UTC

In a weird, twisted, odd, bizarre, strange kind of way, it's sort of cute.

Let's put it this way--it's not the worst Sue I've ever read.

polaris_starz August 31 2003, 04:13:19 UTC

*sporks eyes* Gods. Just... wrong. Ow.

Have you posted a Tonks-Sue here yet? You've not known horror until you've seen OOC-Tonks/Lupin...

koshiroryuu August 31 2003, 16:40:29 UTC

I was reading somewhere recently where someone kept going on and on and on about all the Tonks/Lupin subtext and how it was just so obvious and I just had to look at it and go... erm... wha?

'Cause even if you don't ship Sirius/Remus, I still can't see where there's any hint of Tonks/Remus lovin' anywhere. Can someone explain this to me, please?

And I'm so very afraid of reading any fic that has Tonks as a character. She was cool in canon and all, but the potential for OOC-ness is just so very *there*.

I suppose it could be worse, though. It could be Umbridge seeing the error of her ways and getting a makeover. *shudders dramatically*

theeternalmind August 31 2003, 22:19:31 UTC

>She was cool in canon and all, but the potential for OOC-ness is just so very *there*.

That is so true. As soon as Rowling described her special witch-powers, I thought to myself, /There's going to be a shitload of Tonks-style Sues now, aren't there./ The same goes for taking Tonks OOC.

Actually, now that I think of it, it's kind of funny. Tonks has a Mary Sue name, did you ever notice? ^^ But she hates it, so she has everyone refer to her by her surname~ Yes, I was rather amused by that. ^^

polaris_starz September 1 2003, 00:12:44 UTC

It is sort of a Mary-Sueish name, but the whole Black family has star names and other archaic names, so it's not so out of place. Have we had any metamorphagus (sp?) Sues here yet?