Al Sharpton joins MSNBC

Sep 19, 2011 14:17

As an MSNBC Host, Sharpton Is a Hybrid Like No OtherBy ALAN FEUER ( Read more... )

pundits, lol wut, msnbc, activism

Leave a comment

Comments 7

baked_goldfish September 19 2011, 21:51:30 UTC
If they want him to be

a hybrid TV personality, a journalist-participant of sorts, both a maker and a deliverer of the news

then they're going to have to re-evaluate

NBC’s professional standards [which] bar on-air talent from making donations without managerial consent and from endorsing candidates.

Reply


lone_concertina September 19 2011, 22:12:23 UTC
I've seen a couple of the news shows where he's filled in as host and I didn't think he did too great of a job. At least in the most recent, he couldn't string a coherent sentence together to save his life. The guy speaks for a living, so I don't know if it was the pressure of being an anchor or what, but I'm interested to see why they chose to give him his own show in light of that.

Reply


nothingmuch September 20 2011, 02:27:07 UTC
IDK I kind of like his show. I always used to change the channel when Cenk Uygur would come on, but when Al Sharpton started anchoring instead, I started leaving it on MSNBC.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

doe_witch September 20 2011, 05:02:10 UTC
Well, Sharpton has always struck me as an interesting guy, but I don't know much about him compared to some other activists, even if he's historically gotten more media attention. Over the years I've been mostly struck by how some people take him extremely seriously and some people don't take him seriously at all, so now there seemed to likely be some diversity of opinion about whether it was terrible for him to make this move or if it could wind up being a serious boon to not only his own causes, which I certainly support, but other good ones as well.

Given the lack of comments on this post, maybe the whole thing isn't as ~controversial as I envisioned. But I apologize if that remark of mine you quoted wasn't clear- I don't think he's sold out and I also don't know if this is a great idea, I was just tossing out hypotheticals.

Reply

(The comment has been removed)

doe_witch September 20 2011, 05:16:13 UTC
I apologize for that specifically, then- it's not really language that I would be comfortable using if giving my own opinion, it's language that I could have envisioned others with a more cynical opinion than mine using. But if that came across as my own language, then that was definitely bad phrasing and I fucked up. :\

Reply


veidt September 20 2011, 10:07:19 UTC
So, they fire Cenk for being loud and confrontational... then they wind up hiring Al Sharpton who is even louder and even more confrontational, but mostly really fucking louder?

Reply

nothingmuch September 20 2011, 12:39:07 UTC
On TV at least, Sharpton isn't anywhere near as loud.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up