Review Post: 1x11, 1x12 (Part 1)

Jun 23, 2012 18:08

Many of the reviews are already up so I thought I'd go ahead and make a post for it!

Skeletons in the Closet/Endgame )

episode 1x12, episode 1x11, finale, review

Leave a comment

Comments 131

somnus_angel June 24 2012, 00:01:43 UTC
But ultimately, as happy as I am with almost the entire episode, I can't shake my disappointment in the tacked-on happy ending that was unnecessary and completely ruined the tone of the episode.

ia, the last 5 minutes sucked everything else was great though, but at least it is not Mass Effect 3 bad when it comes to endings

Reply

evilsherbear June 24 2012, 00:06:50 UTC
Hello fellow disappointed ME3 fan :D

Saying its better than the end of ME3 isn't saying much though.

Reply

steotrron June 24 2012, 00:12:23 UTC
BUT MY LEAVES WERE BLUE GREEN GUYS. :'(

Reply

horizongold June 24 2012, 01:17:49 UTC
idk i thought it was close.

Reply


asami June 24 2012, 00:02:29 UTC
WHY DID I GET THE SHORT END OF EVERYTHING

Reply

ikki June 24 2012, 00:04:53 UTC
i know bb you totally got the shaft :(

season 2 ahoy!

(I was very sad that bolin and tarrlok were nowhere to be seen earlier today)

Reply

bolin June 24 2012, 01:41:51 UTC
LJ was being a butt for me :((

Reply

satocycle June 24 2012, 00:14:16 UTC
I was pretty disappointed by that as well. :(

She's lost a lot in all of this and she didn't get anything in return. I mean altruism is cool and shit but damn, give a sister a break.

Reply


steotrron June 24 2012, 00:07:39 UTC
this pretty much sums up what I wish happened at the end.

I really really wonder what season two's going to be about now..continuation of non benders vs. pro benders? Korra no longer has a problem with spirituality I guess because she's Godmodded now..which is disappointing, but I guess I have to live with it.

idk. I'm going to go back to Battlestar Galactica and pretend nothing ever happened

Reply

lady_theta June 24 2012, 00:12:36 UTC
I was really hoping for this kind of ending. This one felt like a rehash of the lion turtle. =_=

Reply

tigerpetals June 25 2012, 02:40:05 UTC
It was rushed but I don't see this as the lion turtle. Aang is not a lion turtle: Avatars have been helping Avatars since the middle of season one of, well Avatar. So Aang helping her out makes sense. All Korra needed was to connect to her spiritual side, which she has been progressively doing all season. It just wasn't always focused on. I think we needed more time seeing her train in the forms to see her progress better. But she started out not being flexible and became light-footed thanks to probending (without which she wouldn't have survived the fight with Tarrlok). She learned all the forms by episode 8, managed to have the full vision in the following episode, and then connected to air in the last. The only flaws are that we didn't see enough of the training, and personally we should have seen her attempt to make the spirit journey herself instead of just having Aang appear without her doing anything to reach him ( ... )

Reply

lady_theta June 25 2012, 03:19:51 UTC
I hadn't thought of Korra attempting suicide until the AV Club reviewer mentioned it.
Maybe this is due to me being overly morbid, but I honestly thought she was attempting suicide. Remember in her mind, she's just lost the one thing that defines her, her bending. Without it, she doesn't consider herself worthy of anything. It would have been interesting to explore that avenue...

Reply


sandstorm June 24 2012, 00:16:54 UTC
katakokk June 25 2012, 00:19:28 UTC
I remember thinking, "Is she going to throw herself off the clip? But...can't she swim?" so I didn't really consider the suicide thing either. It does make the ending more palatable though.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

finalfantasyo13 June 24 2012, 01:32:51 UTC
ugh, all of this exactly.

Reply

yamair June 24 2012, 04:55:35 UTC
Yes, everything was rushed. I knew from the way they handled Tarrlock's bloodbending that this would happen.

Reply

kingsmere June 24 2012, 13:56:42 UTC
Yeah. There's no excuse, really. They had less episodes to work with and therefore less material to look at as a whole and consider what works and what doesn't. They knew they had 12 episodes to work with and should have made it a lot tighter and more evenly paced. If there had have been 20+ episodes it wouldn't have felt so rushed but with the limited run you really feel when the pacing is off.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up