POLL TIIIIIIME

[ivybgreenflower]

PERFORMANCE POLL

You know the drill: Rate the top 11's Elton John butchering.

1 = ear death, 5 = didn't die and maybe kinda liked it.
Spoilers under the cut, so watch out, west coast losers.

Comments

[wheetoo]

I donut like toast

[ivybgreenflower]

ooh, I forgot a do not want option.

[wheetoo]

I just didn't check any little boxes... I'm a rebel like that.

[ivybgreenflower]

omg u rebel

[tyrexus]

Idol Party Rankings

1) Lauren (By far the favorite although I personally hated it.)

2) James
3) Haley
4) Pia
5) Casey
6) Scotty (These 5 were all liked and really close together)

7) Thia

8) Jacob
9) Stefano

10) Paul

11) Naima (The only universally disliked performance)

I'm sure Naima is a goner. Thia and Stefano are in danger.

[irlyneedaname]

casey was soooo good!! and i liked haley for the first time ever:)

[silencefound]

yes to this!!

Casey won my heart and my vote tonight and Haley made me happy she's still around.

[xbringbacklovex]

My personal rankings:
1. Haley
2. Paul
3. Casey
4. Thia
5. Pia
6. Scotty
7. Jacob
8. Naima
9. Stefano
10. Lauren
11. Douchebin

[darlingdivine]

Loved Haley, Pia, Lauren and Casey!

Liked James and Thia!

The others were either mediocre, disappointing or just plain bad.

My bottom 2: Naima and Stefano.

[odontv]

IA with everything except I give Naima props for doing something interesting and I put Paul in the bottom because he's totally awful in every way he even worse the same frickin' clothes.

[darlingdivine]

LOL. How many times has he worn that white suit now? Three?
I wouldn't be too surprised to see him go. He's been very underwhelming during the live shows. The fan outrage would be amusing, lol.

[odontv]

And Scotty's grandma lovin' was A+