Comments | ontd_ai: The ultimate 'American Idol' power ranking

surferxchris in ontd_ai

The ultimate 'American Idol' power ranking

May 31, 2010 16:22

( Read more... )

!season 7, !season 2, !season 8, !season 4, !season 1, !season 5, !season 6, !season 3, !season 9

Comments 102

letitrainblue May 31 2010, 20:25:30 UTC

HOW IS CONSTANTINE ON #7?

IN WHICH UNIVERSE?

surferxchris May 31 2010, 20:26:40 UTC

Lol, ikr? It's ridiculous.

vanya_elda May 31 2010, 20:30:03 UTC

LMAO

goldenskies May 31 2010, 20:57:33 UTC

lol, ikr?

castiels May 31 2010, 20:26:35 UTC

TURBAN!

this is actually kind of the least shocking list i've ever seen.

charliebrown May 31 2010, 20:28:27 UTC

weird list

idontcare_sw May 31 2010, 20:28:39 UTC

How the fuck did Constantine make it so high up?

I honestly haven't heard him spoken of in years and did not think he was THAT great on the show. IDGI

Kris should probs not be that high lets be honest. I think there was definitely a big weight given to more recent contestants since memories of them are fresher etc.

altrus01 May 31 2010, 20:32:01 UTC

"I think there was definitely a big weight given to more recent contestants since memories of them are fresher etc."

Which is sort of the point of a power list, no? Two years from now the top 10 on this list will not be the same unless Idol tanks big time.

idontcare_sw May 31 2010, 20:35:35 UTC

Although that still doesn't explain the conundrum that is Constantine.

binkleywtf May 31 2010, 20:39:00 UTC

I GUESS IT'S BECAUSE OF ROCK OF AGES BUT STILL DNW CONSTANTINE EVER

Thread 10

binkleywtf May 31 2010, 20:28:39 UTC

OBVIOUSLY A SCIENTIFIC POLL. THEIRS IS A FLAWLESS SYSTEM.