Leave a comment

Comments 12

nekobot November 26 2023, 18:36:53 UTC

I'm really curious to see how much the YG name can still help them these days. If you compare this to IVE/NewJeans/Le Seraffim's output they don't stand a chance.

Reply


waves_of_light November 26 2023, 18:44:33 UTC
was waiting for some weird change up or whatever, but the song wasn't that bad? i'm not gonna remember it though. yg has produced monster debuts since 2009, but this was forgettable to me (which is saying a lot because i had to sit and think hard about treasure's). i also don't like the lyrics.

Reply

pseudo_shigure November 26 2023, 20:28:29 UTC

i swear i keep forgetting treasure exists. how are they doing in tho? i know they're not amazingly popular, but i saw some (1?) ad they're doing. so i guess they're still doing well?

Reply

plusnminus November 27 2023, 07:27:00 UTC

pikapika217 November 26 2023, 18:56:39 UTC
This feels very paint by numbers which, considering the multiple young girls in this group & even its name, feels apt. Even considering that YGE groups run on bravado this feels like a generic version tho. Unlike with BP there's no amazing starting point for them to fall from/fall from grace from and it feels unfair to saddle these girls with such dated & boring material. I'm sure they'll do well because its YGE but is there anything even here worth becoming invested in?? Not for me IG!

Reply


pseudo_shigure November 26 2023, 20:30:11 UTC

the song is boring. there's one girl that seems to be really a good performer, she wears yellow hair/braids at one point. and i know the one name pharita. but the rest is kinda just there. also some of the dresses make them look older i feel like. like they're younger than BP when they debuted but their styling in some scenes feels older somehow

Reply


ostsiberia November 26 2023, 23:18:16 UTC
I read a review that says there is nothing here that hasn't already been done by 2ne1 and BP and that captures how I feel.

Reply

xoxkenzxox November 27 2023, 04:48:52 UTC
I'll also throw ITZY in there. The ending gave me strong early ITZY vibes. But yeah.I mean....YG used to be innovative but now it just sounds like something that has been done before.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up