Leave a comment

Comments 40

evilgerbil November 1 2024, 15:44:42 UTC
I didn't even know there was a season 1! I looked it up and the reviews are scathing.

Reply

silverstarry November 1 2024, 15:53:24 UTC
Although there are other issues with the show, Alexandra Daddario is the biggest problem. She’s beautiful but her acting isn’t strong enough this role, which is a huge problem since she’s the main character.

I am trying to hang in until we get an Interview with the Vampire crossover but I don’t know if I’ll make it that long.

Reply

pop_squash November 1 2024, 17:20:50 UTC
Total agreement. Gorgeous, striking eyes, but a pretty terrible actor. She was ~OKAY~ on the white lotus kind of because it didn't demand too much from her, but she really kills Mayfair witches dead.

Reply

no_urges November 1 2024, 17:21:14 UTC
i really hope they rethink any meaningful crossover with IWTV, even if it does make it that far. keep the vampires far away from this hot mess tbh

Reply


ladychips November 1 2024, 15:49:31 UTC

i have this to watch but i keep getting through ep 1 and then im bored enough to put something else on. does it get better?

Reply

green_monsterx November 1 2024, 16:23:57 UTC
no

Reply

ahria November 1 2024, 16:57:00 UTC
It actually gets worse as it goes

Reply

eomir November 1 2024, 20:07:09 UTC
I like a lot of garbage tv, stuff that other people don't like and I hated this. I really enjoyed the books but this is so boring and she's not very good in the role. It was a slog to get through the season. I'm not watching this one.

Reply


maryjanewatson November 1 2024, 15:50:32 UTC
how they managed to butcher this when iwtv is so good i'll never know. and now i'm scared for the talamasca show too.

Reply

insecuredesign November 1 2024, 16:12:20 UTC
I saw photos of Eric filming for it, so here’s hoping he’s used well! He still got the leather jacket band tshirt look lol

Reply

mila_s_garden November 1 2024, 16:27:51 UTC
Yeah, I didn't expect a super faithful adaptation, but this was bad even when you don't compare it with the book

Reply

no_urges November 1 2024, 17:24:56 UTC
it tells me they REALLY struck gold with rolin jones and co. the mayfair witches showrunner seemed like a dumbass who didn't particular get or care for the book series.

i'm a little worried for talamasca too, considering they're going to be coming with a plot whole-cloth with very little to base it on from the books.

Reply


progression November 1 2024, 15:59:44 UTC
I binged through A Discovery of Witches the other week and was so ready for more witch stuff, so I clicked on this and it was so… not good? Like not even the fun-bad that ADoW had at moments. Boo.

Reply


insecuredesign November 1 2024, 16:10:43 UTC

... )

Reply


Leave a comment

Up