ONTD Original: Actors Who Are One Hit Wonders

[off_daze]

We often talk about one-hit wonders in music but there are acting one-hit wonders too! For the purposes of this post, these are actors who only had commercial success with one (main) role.

Comments

[pi_lady]

I will forever associate Hayden with Higher Ground.

[off_daze]

So angsty and emotional. I absolutely loved it!

[pi_lady]

I don't remember any specific storylines but I was like 15 and I was definitely invested. lol And it was the first time I saw AJ Cook, Meghan Ory and Jewel Staite.

[false_hate]

He and A.J. Cook had great chemistry.

And that hot caretaker or whatever. 😏

[alchemic_jedi]

Justice for Brandon Routh’s Superman!

He just got stuck with a bad movie!

[misscrystal25]

Blue Crush?

[queenweasley]

Win A Date With Tad Hamilton was cute, although I don't think it was a big hit.

[ohwutevernvm]

I miss ha. She was everywhere for a hot second. I thought she was going to hit it big. Plus her eyes are so stunning

[nermal_kat]

I'd call Lacey a 2 hit wonder. Or am I overestimating the success of Party of Five?

[blankstare]

No. It was pretty popular when it was out.

[hellojeds]

Party of Five was huge, everyone I knew watched it.

[pciam]

I didn’t watch the show when it aired but yeah I remember it being very popular and got talked about a lot while on air.

[misscrystal25]

Next year all three of them will be in a Halmark Christmas movie where the twist is that one of them is a twin and also a Duke. Which one? We'll find out!

[notoriousreign]

I'd watch that.