'American Pie' Cast Reveals Secret On-Set Crushes 20 Years Later

[evett]

Happy 20th #americanpie !!! #AmericanPie20 pic.twitter.com/RrjO33eh7r
- alyson hannigan (@alydenisof) July 9, 2019

The cast of American Pie reunited to celebrate their 20th anniversary.

Castmate Crushes:- Jason Biggs had a crush on Alyson Hannigan

Comments

[tucker]

Seann William Scott is deff the cutest

[analievelyn]

He's cute! And he seems super sweet

[hanson03]

He was kinda cross eyed

[jarellano89]

I always had a crush on him. I think hes the root of my attraction to trash.

[etoile_amore]

lol I just watched the 1st and 2nd a couple weeks ago for the first time in forever, I still have a crush on Eddie Kay Thomas and Thomas Ian Nicholas (even tho Kevin is whiny af)...Seann is my fave though because he's just sooo not Stifler irl, seems super sweet

[ahkna]

Thomas Ian Nicholas is one of those guys that I just automatically love in things because I watched him in so many kid movies when I was growing up

[stillglows]

i've still never seen any of these movies lol

[lumosofmylife]

Same.

[patty_hewes]

same

[vvitchbaby]

same so i'm surprised to hear Natasha was in it

[sadmagikarp]

[j___adore]

auditions are fucking hard and awkward lol i always feel bad that this came out.

[toshi_hakari]

LMFAO I was hoping that someone posted this while scrolling down and I was not disappointed <3

[squidgiepdx]

I know this is going to sound weird, but Seann William Scott is so much hotter than his character Stiffler.

[j___adore]

that's not weird at all. i feel the same way when i look back at skeet ulrich in the craft and scream. he's so much hotter as a riverdale dad than he ever was.

[squidgiepdx]

I've told friends that Wolverine is a hell of a lot sexier than Hugh Jackman, and they just look at me like I have two heads.

[j___adore]

OHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!! no okay, NOW i see what you're saying. i thought you meant he looks hotter now than he did in the movie. but you're talking about actual stiffler lol